Search This Blog

Featured Post

Introduction

Hello all readers, Welcome to The Parmeter Politics and Policy Record ! My name is Nathan Parmeter, an aspiring public policy professional a...

Showing posts with label 2020 Elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2020 Elections. Show all posts

September 05, 2021

9 Longtime (Presidential) County Voting Streaks that Could End in the Next 9 Years

9 Longtime (Presidential) County Voting Streaks that Could End in the Next 9 Years

Introduction: One of the most significant post-2020 election blog posts last year looked at counties that broke longtime voting streaks for one party. Among the longtime voting streak breakers included a longtime Republican county that voted for a Democrat for the first time (Riley, KS), a longtime Democratic county in South Texas that voted Republican for the first time in a century (Zapata, TX), and a bloc of traditionally-Republican suburban/urban counties that hadn't voted Democratic since 1948, 1964, or 1976. In addition to these flips, other counties with longtime voting streaks saw relatively close margins without flipping. Some of these locales had seen similar conditions in 2016 as the party coalitions began to change with Donald Trump as the Republican nominee. Today's post will go over 9 counties whose presidential voting streak for one party has lasted for at least 60 years and could break during this decade. Some of the counties below were previously featured on a pre-2016 election article on Sabato's Crystal Ball speculating on which counties with longtime voting streaks could flip in 2016 (Wheel).

Table 1: 2008-2020 Presidential Results by County

Data Source: Dave Leip's Database of Election Results (All Presidential), CNN (2018 Midterms), The New York Times (2014 Midterms).

Notes: Each number represents the percentage difference between the winning candidate and losing candidate in each county. 2020, 2016, 2012, and 2008 numbers are from the presidential election from each respective year. As 2018 was a midterm election year, counties from IN, MN, MT, OH, TX, and WI utilized the results from each state's regular Senate election. Since ID did not have a U.S. Senate election in 2018, I utilized its 2018 gubernatorial election results. In the 2014 midterm elections, MN, MT, TN, and TX's results reflect each state's Senate election, while OH and WI did not have Senate elections that year; the 2014 gubernatorial election results are used for both. Indiana did not have either a Senate or Gubernatorial election that year, thus no result is presented for Hamilton County for 2014.

Democratic-Voting Counties:

     Carlton County, MN (last voted Republican in 1928): 

     Image Source: Benbennick, David. "File:Map of Minnesota highlighting Carlton County.svg." Wikimedia Commons, 12 Feb. 2006, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Minnesota_highlighting_Carlton_County.svg. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021.

     The Iron Range has been a longtime Democratic stronghold that has helped all but two post-1928 Democratic Presidential candidates carry Minnesota; Adlai Stevenson in 1956/60 and George McGovern in 1972 are the exceptions. However, its blue tint has weakened under Trump, especially in non-urban areas, due to the region's blue-collar economy (especially mining and logging) witnessing a significant decline in recent decades (Coleman, 88-89; Orenstein). After Trump came onto the scene, Carlton County  narrowly voted for the ex-businessman both times, even after neighboring St. Louis County (containing Duluth and part of the rural Iron Range) slightly swung back after 2016. Although, precinct-level analysis has shown that much of the shift towards Biden in the latter was the result of the city of Duluth becoming more blue, while rural and small-town parts of the county did not budge from the 2016 results (Coleman, 88-89). Nonetheless, the fact that Trump in 2020 actually slightly improved his margin here compared to 2016 is a sign of Carlton's potential short-term prospect of becoming a purple or red-leaning county. 

     Deer Lodge County, MT (last voted Republican in 1924):


     Image Source: Benbennick, David. "File:Map of Montana highlighting Deer Lodge County.svg." Wikimedia Commons, 12 Feb. 2006, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Montana_highlighting_Deer_Lodge_County.svg. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021.

     Deer Lodge County has been voting Democratic longer than Montana counties that have been voting Republican since 1940 (Sullivan; Wheel). This blue-collar county with a historically-significant mining sector has seen significant economic decline in recent decades (Pentilla), and has followed the course of other similar counties during the Trump era, almost voting for Trump both times after voting for Obama twice by double-digits (Table 1). Neighboring Silver Bow County (Butte) also has a fairly-long Democratic voting streak, but did remain more blue in both 2016 and 2020 despite swinging as well, which could be the result of its more urban nature. Despite these top-level trends, Deer Lodge is still relatively-blue downballot, with Democratic Gubernatorial and Senate candidates outrunning Biden in 2020 ("Montana Election"), and Senator Jon Tester winning Deer Lodge by a larger margin than Obama as part of his narrow re-election in 2018 (Table 1).

     Portage County, WI (last voted Republican in 1956): 

     Image Source: Benbennick, David. "File:Map of Wisconsin highlighting Portage County.svg." Wikimedia Commons, 13 Feb. 2006, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Wisconsin_highlighting_Portage_County.svg. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021.

     Except for Barack Obama (D)'s performance in 2008, non-urban (i.e. "Danewaukee") Wisconsin is an increasingly-red area, but Stevens Point's Portage County is an exception, even if it has become less blue itself. Nonetheless, after voting for Obama twice by double-digits, the county narrowly voted for both Clinton and Biden (Table 1), and even became slightly more red in 2020. In the next few cycles, Portage County could potentially be a bellwether of Wisconsin's future electoral shifts, especially if it and the state continue to trend more Republican.

     Starr County, TX (last voted Republican in 1892): 

     Image Source: Benbennick, David. "File:Map of Texas highlighting Starr County.svg." Wikimedia Commons, 12 Feb. 2006, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Texas_highlighting_Starr_County.svg. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021.

     One of the 2020 Presidential Election's most talked-about results was Donald Trump (R)'s unexpectedly good showing in South Texas's majority-Latino region, where some counties shifted over 50% more Republican from 2016 (Rothschilds)! As detailed earlier, he became the first Republican since Warren Harding (R) to win Zapata County, and came extremely close to winning neighboring Starr, which is one of the few counties with a Democratic presidential voting streak stretching back over a century. In fact, other than a bloc of South Texas counties, before 2020, only Northampton County, North Carolina (a majority-Black county in the state's northeast) had a Democratic voting streak stretching back a century (Davis; Sullivan). Whether Trump's gains in this region were a one-off event or permanent remains to be seen, but Starr County's electoral results in the upcoming midterm and 2024 presidential elections will give a clear indication of whether it reverts to the pre-2020 environment or takes on the new trend. 

Republican-Voting Counties:

      Ada County, ID (last voted Democratic in 1936): 

     Image Source: Benbennick, David. "File:Map of Idaho highlighting Ada County.svg." Wikimedia Commons, 12 Feb. 2006, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Idaho_highlighting_Ada_County.svg. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021.

     A 2017 New Yorker piece about the "Red State, Blue City" effect highlighted Boise as a prime example of this Trump-era electoral trend, noting its highly-educated and young population, and the increasing presence of amenities serving these groups that are correlated with increased Democratic support (Davidson). The last time a Democratic presidential candidate won Idaho (1964), Boise's Ada County was not part of that coalition, as it had started voting red in 1940 (Sullivan). Yet, in recent cycles, Ada County has become less red to the point where Joe Biden came within 5 points of picking up Idaho's most-populated county, and both the 2014 and 2018 Gubernatorial candidates won Ada ("Governor Election"; Table 1). Reason for this shift include its high rate of education attainment and its Mormon population that Trump underperformed with in the 2016 primary, as well as its increasingly-young population, as noted above (Davidson; Wheel).

     Hamilton County, IN (last voted Democratic in 1916): 

     Image Source: Benbennick, David. "File:Map of Indiana highlighting Hamilton County.svg." Wikimedia Commons, 12 Feb. 2006, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Indiana_highlighting_Hamilton_County.svg. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021.

     Since World War I, Indiana has only voted blue four times (1932, 1936, 1964, 2008), with Hamilton County's Republican voting streak encompassing that whole period (Sullivan). But, there is a good possibility that this streak could break during this decade due to the massive electoral shifts occurring nationwide and here in the Trump era. For context, Hamilton County is a wealthy and very college-educated suburban county north of Indianapolis that gave Mitt Romney 67% in 2012 (hoosieraaron). But, with Trump in the picture, the county has shifted hard left, coming within 10% of Joe Biden (D)'s reach last year, which represents a major swing since 2012 (Table 1). In 2020, Hamilton County's Congressional District, IN-5, became a competitive race when Rep. Susan Brooks (R) decided to retire. While Republican nominee Victoria Spartz held the seat against Christina Hale (D), the margin was competitive, with Hamilton County only voting for Spartz by 11% ("Indiana House; "Republican Victoria").

     Carver County, MN (last voted Democratic in 1932): 

     Image Source: Benbennick, David. "File:Map of Minnesota highlighting Carver County.svg." Wikimedia Commons, 12 Feb. 2006, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Minnesota_highlighting_Carver_County.svg. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021.

     While Minnesota's formerly-blue rural areas such as Carlton County have become less blue recently, the Twin Cities suburbs have become a newly-formed "firewall" for statewide Democrats, with Joe Biden's performance there helping swing the state left (Coleman, 89-90; Eligon; Montgomery). While suburban Carver County has yet to vote Democratic, it came very close in 2020 as the blue tint from Hennepin began to wash over the county boundary. Like other historically-Republican suburban counties nationwide that voted or nearly voted for Clinton and Biden after voting red, Carver County is highly-affluent, economically-prosperous, increasingly-young, and increasingly connected to the Twin Cities Metro (Felegy; Miller). These traits match that of other once-red suburban, suburban/exurban, and urban counties that have become less red or even turned blue under Trump, including those listed both above and below this entry.

     Delaware County, OH (last voted Democratic in 1916): 

     Image Source: Benbennick, David. "File:Map of Ohio highlighting Delaware County.svg." Wikimedia Commons, 12 Feb. 2006, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Ohio_highlighting_Delaware_County.svg. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021.

     In the midst of Ohio's massive pro-Republican shift under Trump, the home county of ex-Governor and high-profile Trump critic John Kasich (R) has become a notable exception. In many ways, Delaware County is almost similar to Hamilton County in many ways, such as its voting streak dating back to 1916 and seeing the exact same margin in 2020, although the two had been voting relatively the same in the last few cycles (Table 1). But, in what seems like a broken record, Delaware County is largely suburban, wealthy, and highly-educated, and has seen a significant shift during the Trump era (Coleman, 93). And like Hamilton, IN, Delaware's shift already began in the middle of Trump's term, which became evident in the August 2018 special election in Delaware County's Congressional District, OH-12. In that election, Republican Troy Balderson narrowly won the district over Democrat Danny O'Connor, with Delaware voting for Balderson by less than 10% (Brownstein). Several months later, Senator Sherrod Brown (D) also lost Delaware County by single-digits as part of his third election victory (Table 1). And, despite Ohio barely moving between the 2016 and 2020 presidential elections, Delaware voted for Donald Trump (R) by a similar margin to its 2018 margins, but far narrower than 2016, which in turn was a massive shift from 2012 (Table 1). With these results in mind, Delaware County seems primed to vote blue sometime this decade, assuming the Trump-era electoral coalitions and shifts continue.

     Knox County, TN (last voted Democratic in 1940): 

     
     Image Source: Benbennick, David. "File:Map of Tennessee highlighting Knox County.svg." Wikimedia Commons, 12 Feb. 2006, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Tennessee_highlighting_Knox_County.svg. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021.

     Eastern Tennessee has been a Republican stronghold since the party was first allowed on the ballot in the region, which is no surprise considering the region's massive opposition to the Confederacy and the pre-Civil war Democratic Party that almost resulted it becoming its own state vis-à-vis West Virginia (Garrett). In fact, a group of counties in this region (and neighboring KY and NC) have not voted for any Democratic presidential candidates for over a century, which includes the nationwide sweeps under both FDR and LBJ (Sullivan). In the midst of this cluster is the most urban and least red, Knox County, home of Knoxville. While its 2020 results still make it more red than the other counties on this list, Knox County deserves to be mentioned because of it becoming a unique electoral sore thumb in a region that has been dark red for a long time, and its additional potential for it to shift even further if the current coalitions continue due to its urban nature. 

Table 1 Data Sources:

"2004 Presidential General Election Results." David Leip's Atlas of U.S. Presidential Elections, uselectionatlas.org/RESULTS/. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

"2008 Presidential General Election Results." David Leip's Atlas of U.S. Presidential Elections, uselectionatlas.org/RESULTS/. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

"2012 Presidential General Election Results." David Leip's Atlas of U.S. Presidential Elections, uselectionatlas.org/RESULTS/. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

"2016 Presidential General Election Results." David Leip's Atlas of U.S. Presidential Elections, uselectionatlas.org/RESULTS/. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

"2020 Presidential General Election Results." David Leip's Atlas of U.S. Presidential Elections, uselectionatlas.org/RESULTS/. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

"Governor Election Results 2014." The New York Times, last modified 17 Dec. 2014, www.nytimes.com/elections/2014/results/governor?utm_source=top_nav&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=election-2014. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

"National Results." CNN, www.cnn.com/election/2018/results. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.
  • 2018 Election Results
"Senate Election Results 2014." The New York Times, last modified 17 Dec. 2014, www.nytimes.com/elections/2014/results/senate?utm_source=top_nav&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=election-2014. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

Works Cited: 

Brownstein, Ronald. "The Ohio Results Point to Democratic Strength in 2018—And a Showdown in 2020." The Atlantic, 8 Aug. 2018, www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/08/trump-oconnor-balderson-ohio-special-election/567050/. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

Coleman, J. Miles. "A Political Road Trip Across the Country." A Return to Normalcy?, edited by J. Miles Coleman, Kyle Kondik, and Larry J. Sabato, Rowman and Littlefield, pp. 81-99.

Coleman, J. Miles, Kyle Kondik, and Larry J. Sabato, editors. A Return to Normalcy? The 2020 Election That (Almost) Broke America, Rowman and Littlefield, 2021.

Davidson, Justin. "Cities Vs. Trump." Intelligencer, The New Yorker, 17 Apr. 2017, nymag.com/intelligencer/2017/04/the-urban-rural-divide-matters-more-than-red-vs-blue-state.html. Accessed 4 Sept. 2021.

Davis, Ben. "The 10 swing state counties that tell the story of the 2020 election." The Guardian, 24 Nov. 2020, www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/nov/24/the-10-swing-state-counties-that-tell-the-story-of-the-2020-election. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021. 

Eligon, John. "How a Minneapolis Suburb Turned Blue, Despite Trump’s Law-and-Order Pitch." The New York Times, 16 Nov. 2020, www.nytimes.com/2020/11/16/us/biden-suburbs-blue-minneapolis.html. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

Felegy, Amy. "Carver County Republican-DFL gap shrinks." Southwest News Media, 12 Nov. 2020, www.swnewsmedia.com/chanhassen_villager/news/election/carver-county-republican-dfl-gap-shrinks/article_ed922a40-aa0a-5938-aa9c-1f00bc88aff7.html. Accessed 4 Sept. 2021.

Garrett, Ben. "How Scott County became Tennessee’s most Republican county." The Independent Herald, 9 Nov. 2020, www.ihoneida.com/2020/11/09/how-scott-county-became-tennessees-most-republican-county/. Accessed 4 Sept. 2021.

hoosieraaron. "Biden Republicans are real and they live in Carmel, Indiana." Daily Kos, 12 Apr. 2021, www.dailykos.com/stories/2021/4/12/2025450/-Biden-Republicans-are-real-and-they-live-in-Carmel-Indiana. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

"Indiana House Election Results and Maps 2020." CNN, last modified 6 Mar. 2021, www.cnn.com/election/2020/results/state/indiana/house/district-5. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

Miller, Derek. "The Happiest Places in America – 2018 Edition. SmartAsset, 12 Jun. 2018, smartasset.com/mortgage/happiest-places-in-america-2018-edition. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

"Montana Election Results and Maps 2020." CNN, last modified 6 Mar. 2021, www.cnn.com/election/2020/results/state/montana. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

Montgomery, David H. "Facts don't support GOP Chair Carnahan's election claims." Minnesota Public Radio, 20 Nov. 2020, www.mprnews.org/story/2020/11/20/mngop-chairs-election-claims-unsupported-by-facts. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

Orenstein, Walker. "What we learned from the Greater Minnesota vote in 2020." Minnesota Post, 5 Nov. 2020, www.minnpost.com/greater-minnesota/2020/11/what-we-learned-from-the-greater-minnesota-vote-in-2020/. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

Pentilla, Annie. "Anaconda economic development advocates bet on downtown revitalization as winning strategy." Helena Independent Record, 29 Jan. 2017, helenair.com/business/anaconda-economic-development-advocates-bet-on-downtown-revitalization-as-winning-strategy/article_3d8faf29-caf6-52a5-baa9-2af157fc9895.html. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

"Republican Victoria Spartz wins election to U.S. House in Indiana’s 5th Congressional District." CBS4 Indianapolis, 4 Nov. 2020, cbs4indy.com/news/vote-count-continues-in-tight-indiana-congressional-race/. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021.

Rothschild, Neal. "Four demographic trends that explain Biden's victory." Axios, 11 Nov. 2020, www.axios.com/election-biden-trump-demographics-639b6c8e-6e5c-43c8-962f-dca6a127c4ef.html. Accessed 5 Sept. 2021. 

Sullivan, Robert David. "How the red and blue map evolved over the past century." America: The Jesuit Review, 29 Jun. 2016, www.americamagazine.org/content/unconventional-wisdom/how-red-and-blue-map-evolved-over-past-century. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021. 

Wheel, Robert. "The 2016 Streak Breakers." Sabato's Crystal Ball, 6 Oct. 2016, centerforpolitics.org/crystalball/articles/the-2016-streak-breakers/. Accessed 2 Sept. 2021. 

Whetstone, Tyler. "Longtime Knox County GOP insider Dean Rice is leaving the party. He wants to tell you why." knox news, 21 Aug. 2021, www.knoxnews.com/story/news/politics/2021/08/19/knox-county-gop-insider-dean-rice-leaving-party/5487127001/. Accessed 4 Sept. 2021.

July 18, 2021

A post-2008 Electoral Tale of Two Wisconsins: "Danewaukee" vs. "Rest of Wisconsin"

A post-2008 Electoral Tale of Two Wisconsins: "Danewaukee" vs. "Rest of Wisconsin"

Introduction: I like to summarize Wisconsin's post-2008 electoral politics as "Madison and Milwaukee vs. everywhere else," a description I know is simultaneously very simplistic and truthful to an extent. In 2008, Barack Obama won a 13% victory in the Badger State, and as we will see below, performed well in both Dane and Milwaukee counties ("Danewaukee") and the rest of Wisconsin ("RoW"). Not within two years, Wisconsin swung back hard, with the Governor's mansion, two House seats and Senator Russ Feingold's seat turning red ("Wisconsin"). Since then, as we will see below, the two regions have electorally diverged, with every winning Republican doing so off of "RoW" and every Democrat off of "Danewaukee." Considering Wisconsin's recent electoral politics, I find this personal theory to be worthy of quantitative exploration to determine the extent to which it is true. 

Table 1: Significant 2008-2020 Wisconsin Election Results

Note: The 2012 Gubernatorial election was an off-cycle recall election in June 2012. During this time period explored above, "Danewaukee" generally casted around 25% of the statewide vote while "Rest of Wisconsin" casted around 75%, give or take a percent or two. 

Data Source: "More Wisconsin." 

Significant 2008-2020 Elections:
  • 2010 Gubernatorial: Going into the 2010 Gubernatorial Election, incumbent Jim Doyle (D) decided not to run for another term due to his declining popularity ("Republican Walker"). Ex-U.S. Representative and Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett (D) received the Democratic nomination, while the Republican nominee was State Legislator Scott Walker (R) (Hiskes). Walker won his first term by over 5%, concurrent with the Republican Senate victory (below) (Rocha). One of the most significant issues in this election was Governor Doyle's aspirations to extend the Chicago-Milwaukee Hiawatha Service Amtrak service to Madison, which included the purchase of two new trainsets specifically for the extension. Walker was heavily opposed to the extension, (among other things) arguing it would be fiscally unsustainable and that it would benefit only Madison and Milwaukee at the expense of the rest of the state (Bowman and Johnson). Gov. Doyle ended up halting the project and returning Federal funding right after Walker's victory (Sandler). The reason I wanted to mention this specific campaign issue is because Governor Walker's tactic of promising that "RoW" would take back power from "Danewaukee" would be echoed by Trump 6 years later, who rode on non-urban resentment as part of his shocking win of Wisconsin (Johnson, "Kevin"). Furthermore, it is notable that post-2008, no major Democratic nominee has won "RoW," reflecting the region's massive shift from Barack Obama's showing in 2008, and the increasingly-sharp electoral differences between the two regions explored here that started with the 2010 elections. 
  • 2010 Senate: Just two years after Barack Obama (D) had won Wisconsin by almost 15% as part of his historic victory, Wisconsin was about to swing all the way around in a dramatic fashion. Progressive Senator Russ Feingold (D) ran for a third term, and faced a difficult race against businessman Ron Johnson (R). His 2010 struggles were considered surprising because Feingold had previously beat back tough challenges, was well-liked, and was in a state that hadn't voted Republican for President in a while (Woodruff). Senator Feingold eventually lost by 4% to Johnson as the Tea Party wave washed over the country and Wisconsin ("Wisconsin"). 
  • 2012 Gubernatorial Recall: Liberal backlash to Governor Walker (R) was quick to emerge after his 2010 election victory. In particular, successful Republican legislation to weaken public labor bargaining galvanized a recall effort against the Governor that made it onto the ballot in June 2012. Despite intense energy behind the pro-recall effort, Governor Walker survived the recall election against Barrett, with RoW backing him heavily (Table 1). Gov. Walker thus became the first Governor in American history to survive a recall election, and only the third to face one at the time (Peralta). In this year, California will have a gubernatorial recall election in September (Blood and Ronayne), while Alaska has an ongoing (as of July 2021) gubernatorial recall movement that could result in a recall election. "RoW" gave a significant margin to Walker, as he won the region by 20%, something that not even Trump pulled off in 2016 or 2020 despite his extensive appeal there. 
  • 2012 Senate: In 2012, incumbent Senator Herb Kohl (D), who previously co-founded and led the Kohl's department store chain, decided to retire after a multi-decade political career (Gunn). U.S. Representative Tammy Baldwin (D) won the seat against ex-Governor Tommy Thompson (R), thus becoming the first Senator identifying as homosexual (Goldenberg). Simultaneously, Wisconsin's blue hue further returned as Barack Obama (D) won the state by over 6% (Table 1). 
  • 2014 Gubernatorial: Having survived the recall election, Governor Walker ran for a full second term in 2014. His challenger was Mary Burke (D), a former businesswoman for the Trek bicycle company and a State Commerce Secretary under ex-Governor Doyle (D) (o'Brien). Governor Walker easily netted a second term, making it the third election in four years he had won. Burke's attempt to defeat the incumbent Governor was complicated by low turnout among Democratic base groups, Walker's good performance among independent voters, and a dismal Democratic performance in Dane and Milwaukee Counties (Rocha). 
  • 2016 Senate: Going into the 2016 Senate elections, Senate Republicans were thought to be in a tough situation, with them holding 7 seats in states won by President Barack Obama (D) as part of his 2012 re-election, several in (at the time) fairly blue states. Among these was Senator Ron Johnson (R), who was considered the most vulnerable due to his conservative voting record in a then light-blue (presidential-wise) state (Kondik). Ex-Senator Russ Feingold (D) ran in a rematch to reclaim his former seat, and was considered a favorite for most of the cycle (Meyer). In the closing days, the Senate race saw tightening polls and an influx of outside spending to support the candidates (Meyer; Rahman). On Election Day, Senator Johnson pulled off a shocking upset in parallel with Donald Trump (R)'s unexpected win of the Badger State ("Trump Wins").  Had Feingold won in 2016, he would have been the first Senator to lose to a challenger and make a comeback through unseating the same challenger since the 1930s (Bauer, "Republican"). 
  • 2018 Gubernatorial: With a Blue Wave year hitting the country, state and national Democrats salivated at the possibly of finally being able to unseat Governor Walker after two unsuccessful attempts. In the time since the last gubernatorial election, Walker had run for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination before dropping out early in the nomination cycle, despite him being seen as a frontrunner just months before (Kondik et al.). State Education Chief Tony Evers (D) gained the Democratic nomination and ended up winning narrowly against Walker, although he came into office facing a Republican-controlled legislature (Bauer, "Wisconsin Democrats"). 
  • 2018 Senate: Senator Baldwin (D) ran for another term in 2018, and ended up winning by double-digits. Her opponent was State Legislator Leah Vukmir (R), who had won the nomination against businessman Kevin Nicholson (R), an ex-Democrat who previously was previously President of the College Democrats of America (Glauber; Johnson, "Kevin"). 
Analysis and Implications: As noted in the above section, it stands out that since 2008, no Democratic nominee for U.S. President, U.S. Senate, or Wisconsin Governor has won "RoW," including Senator Baldwin (D), whose 2018 double-digit win was on the back of "Danewaukee" alone. To show the extent of this divergence, even Obama 2012's and Biden's victories in Wisconsin relied alone on a solid margin in "Danewaukee." With the exception of Senator Baldwin's 2018 re-election, every Republican candidate since 2008 has netted double-digit margins from "RoW," thus requiring a significant margin out of "Danewaukee" for a Democrat to win. In particular, the massive jump in RoW's Republican net margin between the 2012 and 2016 Presidential elections stands out, as does the similar % margin in 2020. These results seem to indicate that the Republican Party's Trump-era electoral shift has permanently made the region more red in presidential year elections in addition to midterm elections, thus making the state more competitive than it used to be. This is despite now-President Joe Biden (D) further increasing the "Danewaukee" net vote margin compared to both Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama's performances, yet losing and narrowly winning Wisconsin due to the double-digit Republican margins in "RoW." 

Beside Trump, the results presented on Table 1 also reflect on a key reason behind the failure of Democratic candidates to win against Governor Walker (R) until 2018, which is the relatively lower turnout in Wisconsin's gubernatorial elections, which are held in midterm years. The lower-than-presidential margins in "Danewaukee" reflect this during each of Walker's campaigns. Furthermore, Walker's obvious strength in "RoW" complicated such efforts, as was his relatively good performance in "Danewaukee" for a Republican. Even in the 2012 recall election, when turnout was relatively high, Walker survived due to his massive raw vote margin in "RoW," while the Democratic net margin increase in "Danewaukee" was nowhere close to even match the former's pro-Republican shift, thus showing Walker's intense support from that region. 

While I am not into the business of creating complex quantitative models to predict what percentages a candidate would need to win a race, some clues stand out in the table above. In particular, it seems as though any Republican hoping to win the state needs to net at least a 14% winning margin in "RoW," with the threshold being lower in low-turnout midterms (such as 2010 or 2014). This can also be achieved with a better-than-normal performance in "Danewaukee," especially among independent voters (something Scott Walker achieved in his three successful elections). Furthermore, with the massive pro-Republican shift in "RoW," a 40%+ winning margin in "Danewaukee" is paramount for a Democrat to narrowly win, as is reducing the Republican margin in "RoW" as much as possible. Remember back to the note under Table 1 that "Danewaukee" and "RoW" accounted for around 25% and 75% of the statewide vote in the time period studied, which further emphasizes the importance of "RoW" for an aspiring statewide candidate of either party. 

Conclusion: Even though this blog's analysis of Wisconsin's election results started with 2008, it is noteworthy that Dane and Milwaukee have been voting Democratic in Presidential elections starting in 1960, longer than other urban Midwestern counties such as Cuyahoga (Cleveland), Marion (Indianapolis), Hennepin (Minneapolis), and even Chicago's Cook (Sullivan). Thus, it could be argued that while the electoral differences between the two regions predate the rise of Scott Walker (R), his campaign rhetoric and policies heavily exasperated the divide between the two regions, which is further strengthened by Trump's appeal in "RoW." 

Based on the election results analyzed above plus the above paragraph, another way to summarize post-2008 Wisconsin politics is "the winner's electoral performance in the RoW matters significantly," especially since "Danewaukee" has continuously cast only 25% of the statewide vote despite becoming more Democratic, while "RoW" has trended red since 2008, only snapping back in 2012 and somewhat in 2018. This will likely continue to hold true for the foreseeable future, thus keeping Wisconsin in the group of core swing states. With Senate and Gubernatorial elections taking place in Wisconsin next year, the statewide winners of both are likely to do so off the back of either, but not both regions.

Works Cited: 

Bauer, Scott. "Republican Johnson defeats Feingold in rematch of 2010 race." StarTribune, 8 Nov. 2016, www.startribune.com/johnson-feingold-in-rematch-of-2010-wisconsin-senate-race/400358961/. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

---. "Wisconsin Democrats rejoice: Scott Walker is finally gone." Associated Press, 7 Nov. 2018, apnews.com/article/donald-trump-ap-top-news-wisconsin-wi-state-wire-scott-walker-9b28173f43b44cfa9ba64438d002f075. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Blood, Michael, and Kathleen Ronayne. "Who’s in? California recall candidate list draws confusion." Associated Press, 18 Jul. 2021, apnews.com/article/entertainment-health-government-and-politics-elections-california-c5eedc7f144b2e7baa5745b800e67709. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Bowden, Bridget, and Shawn Johnson. "As Political Winds Change, Walker Uses Train to Seize the Moment." Wisconsin Public Radio, 23 Oct. 2019, www.wpr.org/derailed/political-winds-change-walker-uses-train-seize-moment. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Glauber, Bill. "Six takeaways from Tammy Baldwin's victory in Wisconsin U.S. Senate race." Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, 7 Nov. 2018, www.jsonline.com/story/news/politics/elections/2018/11/07/six-takeaways-tammy-baldwins-victory-wisconsin-u-s-senate-race/1909528002/. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021.

Goldenberg, Suzanne. "Tammy Baldwin wins in Wisconsin as voters elect first openly gay senator." The Guardian, 7 Nov. 2012, www.theguardian.com/world/2012/nov/07/wisconsin-senate-results-tammy-baldwin. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Gunn, Erik. "Retiring Sen. Herb Kohl got a lot done while shunning the spotlight." Isthmus, 4 Oct. 2012, isthmus.com/news/news/retiring-sen-herb-kohl-got-a-lot-done-while-shunning-the-spotlight/. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Hiskes, Jonathan. "Wisconsin governor's race: Barrett vs. Walker." Grist, 11 Oct. 2010, grist.org/article/2010-wisconsin-governors-race/. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Johnson, Shawn. "Kevin Nicholson Stresses Military Service In GOP Bid For US Senate." Wisconsin Public Radio, 2 Aug. 2018, www.wpr.org/kevin-nicholson-stresses-military-service-gop-bid-us-senate. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

---. "Trump's Wisconsin Win Leaves Many Wondering What Happened." Wisconsin Public Radio, 10 Nov. 2016, www.wpr.org/trumps-wisconsin-win-leaves-many-wondering-what-happened. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Kondik, Kyle. "Senate 2016: The Republicans’ 2012 Homework." Sabato's Crystal Ball, 11 Dec. 2014, centerforpolitics.org/crystalball/articles/senate-2016-the-republicans-2012-homework/. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Kondik, Kyle, Larry Sabato, and Geoffrey Skelley. "Republicans 2016: Two down, 14 to go." Sabato's Crystal Ball, 24 Sept. 2015, centerforpolitics.org/crystalball/articles/republicans-2016-two-down-14-to-go/. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Meyer, Theodoric. "Johnson upsets Feingold to keep Wisconsin Senate seat." Politico, 9 Nov. 2016, www.politico.com/story/2016/11/johnson-feingold-wisconsin-senate-race-2016-election-results-231027. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

"More Wisconsin Elections Results." Wisconsin Elections Administration, elections.wi.gov/elections-voting/results-all. Accessed 12 Jul. 2021.

o'Brien, Brendan. "Poll shows race for Wisconsin governor is a dead heat." Reuters, 21 May 2014, www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-politics-wisconsin/poll-shows-race-for-wisconsin-governor-is-a-dead-heat-idUSBREA4K14P20140521. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Peralta, Eyder. "Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker Survives Recall." National Public Radio, 5 Jun. 2012, www.npr.org/sections/itsallpolitics/2012/06/05/154384654/live-blog-wisconsin-decides-governors-fate-in-recall-vote. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Rahman, Rema. "Republican Sen. Ron Johnson Holds On to Wisconsin Senate Seat." The Hill, 8 Nov. 2016, www.rollcall.com/2016/11/08/republican-sen-ron-johnson-holds-on-to-wisconsin-senate-seat/. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

"Republican Walker Defeats Barrett to Win Wisconsin Governor's Race." Fox News, 2 Nov. 2010, www.foxnews.com/politics/republican-walker-defeats-barrett-to-win-wisconsin-governors-race. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021.

Rocha, Polo. "How Scott Walker won his third governor’s race in four years." The Badger Herald, 6 Nov. 2014, badgerherald.com/news/2014/11/06/how-scott-walker-won-his-third-governors-race-in-four-years/. Accessed 16 Jul. 2021. 

Sandler, Larry. "Doyle says canceling rail line will cost $100 million, cut 400 jobs." Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Archive, 8 Nov. 2010, archive.jsonline.com/news/wisconsin/106914208.html/. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

Sullivan, Robert David. "How the red and blue map evolved over the past century." America: The Jesuit Review, 29 Jun. 2016, www.americamagazine.org/content/unconventional-wisdom/how-red-and-blue-map-evolved-over-past-century. Accessed 16 Jul. 2021.  

"Trump Wins Wisconsin, State Senate and Assembly Republicans Maintain Majorities." The Hamilton Consulting Group, L.L.C, 9 Nov. 2016, www.hamilton-consulting.com/2016-election-results-2/. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

"Wisconsin - Election Results 2010." The New York Times, www.nytimes.com/elections/2010/results/wisconsin.html. Accessed 16 Jul. 2021. 

Woodruff, Judy. "In Wisconsin, Feingold in Tough Senate Battle With ‘Outsider’ Businessman." PBS NewsHour, 5 Oct. 2010, www.pbs.org/newshour/show/in-wisconsin-feingold-in-tough-senate-battle-with-outsider-businessman. Accessed 18 Jul. 2021. 

July 11, 2021

Colorado's Last Red Hue: What Drove Cory Gardner's 2014 Statewide Win?

Colorado's Last Red Hue: Examining Cory Gardner's 2014 Senate Victory

Introduction: Last month, I posted a Tableau-made bubble diagram on Twitter showing county-level change in net votes between the 2008 and 2020 Presidential Elections in Colorado. During this time period, Colorado started as a light-blue/purple state, but has rapidly become a nearly-solid blue state since Donald Trump (R) entered the national stage in mid-2015. Yet, the year prior witnessed a significant electoral moment for the Centennial State, as Representative Cory Gardner (R) narrowly won that year's U.S. Senate race in a state President Barack Obama (D) won by 6% two years prior (Navarro; Sarlin). Despite Gardner serving only one term, his 2014 win is significant when considering the significant electoral shift that has occurred since, which can lead to questions of how he even pulled off a narrow victory in the state whose name's origin reflects the color of his party. Today's post will explore election data to determine what electoral factors led to Gardner's victory. 

Counties of Colorado: Visual 1 below displays the names and locations of Colorado's counties, as I will be referencing them throughout this blog post. 

Visual 1: Counties of Colorado

Data Sources: "File:Colorado-counties-map.png." Wikimedia Commons, 12 Apr. 2011, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Colorado-counties-map.png. Accessed 10 Jul. 2021. 

2008 and 2014: In 2008, incumbent Senator Wayne Allard (R) retired after serving two terms. In parallel with Barack Obama (D)'s historic victory in Colorado, Representative Mark Udall (D), member of a multi-state political family, easily won the seat over Republican Bob Schaffer ("Democrat wins"). 

Six years later, in a familiar story that has defined American electoral politics in recent decades, the tables turned on Udall, despite Obama winning the state a second time by over 5% in 2012. Representative Cory Gardner, a freshman from the 2010 Red Wave who unseated incumbent Rep. Betsy Markey (D) by 11% in 2010, jumped into the Senate race at the last minute after Republicans initially failed to recruit a high-quality candidate (Sarlin; Tomasic). Gardner went on to narrowly defeat Sen. Udall as part of the GOP's 9-seat gain in the upper chamber (Kondik; Sarlin). Visual 2 below depicts the county-level results from both Senate races. Even without reading the rest of this blog, the massive Republican shift across the state stands out. 

Visual 2: County Map Results

Data Sources: "2014 Abstract," "Official Publication"

Analysis of Election Results and Electoral Shifts: 
     2008-2014 Regional Results and Significant Changes: Between the 2008 and 2014 Senate elections, Colorado swung 11% towards the GOP. As seen on Visual 3, every county became more Republican, although the exact shift was variable. In particular, the rural High Plains counties east of Denver and Colorado Springs saw significant pro-GOP shifts, with some county margins becoming over 20% more Republican. Something that can explain this shift (in addition to partisan changes and the national environment) is increased conflict between the region and Denver over the state's increasingly liberal energy standards. Oil and gas drilling is an increasingly-important industry in this region, and fuels the sense of alienation with Denver. A year prior to the 2014 election, a bloc of counties in this region voted on whether to split off from Colorado and form a new state. Several counties eventually voted in favor of secession (Camron), notably Yuma, which saw the largest pro-Republican swing between the 2008 and 2014 Senate elections (36.21%). In Colorado's northwest corner, Moffat County (home to Dinosaur National Monument) voted for a similar measure to join Wyoming ("Election Results 2013"), and saw a pro-Republican swing by a similar margin the following year. As detailed in the next paragraph, that portion of the state has similar cultural and economic attributes.  

In parallel with the trend on the High Plains, the "western slope" counties bordering Utah saw similar swings, including a the contiguous quartet of counties containing the Republican-voting cities of Mesa (Grand Junction), Delta (Delta), Montrose (Montrose), and purple-leaning Garfield County (Rifle and Glenwood Springs). Like the Plains counties, this region relies heavily on oil and gas extraction, which might be a significant explanation for this swing (Webb). As I detailed in a Twitter map this morning to commemorate the first anniversary of my Twitter account and reaching 200 followers on it last week, the aforementioned former trio of counties didn't even vote for ex-Representative John Salazar (D) in 2008, whose 25% win of CO-3 included some normally-red rural counties. Today, this region is the home base of controversial U.S. Representative Lauren Boebert (R), who won CO-3 in 2020 after defeating incumbent Rep. Scott Tipton (R) in the primary. Tipton had represented the expansive district since defeating Salazar in 2010. 

In the south-central part of the state bordering New Mexico lies a group of majority-Latino counties, all of which saw a significant electoral shift between the 2008 and 2014 Senate elections. This region's once-strong Democratic heritage has melted away in recent years, with Joe Biden (D) only winning longtime blue Costilla County, which hasn't voted Republican since 1924 (Sullivan). In 2016, multiple counties around Costilla flipped from blue to red, and except for Pueblo County, all stayed with Trump in 2020, who also flipped Alamosa (Frank and Osgood). This region is also home to several of the largest electoral swings in counties that flipped parties between the two Senate elections, Conejos and Las Animas. Both gave Udall double-digit margins in 2008, but voted for Gardner in 2014, with Las Animas voting for Gardner by 7% (thus shifting 5 colors on the scale used on Visual 2). 

Finally, the already-blue mountain counties only moved slightly more red, including most of the ski resort- and tourist-dominated counties such as Eagle (Vail), Pitkin (Aspen), and San Miguel (Telluride). Boulder County, home to the state's flagship university, saw the smallest pro-Republican swing in the state, at around 2.04%. Metro Denver's counties saw significant margin shifts in favor of Gardner, but considering that the bulk of the state's population lives here, such shifts were probably critical for Gardner to win. Per Visual 2, the three suburban counties directly ringing Denver (starting north and going clockwise), Adams, Arapahoe, and Jefferson, all narrowly voted for Udall in 2014, with all three swinging 10-15% right compared to 2008. These counties have since swung left under Trump, helping secure Colorado's status as an increasingly-blue state (Frank and Osgood). Yet, these counties (especially Jefferson) contain a high number of independent voters (Markus), a group that Gardner performed well with in 2014 (Sarlin). 

     Visual 3: Changes in County-Level % Margins

     Data Sources: "2014 Abstract," "Official Publication"

     Change in Total Turnout: Visual 4 below shows the percentage change in total turnout between the 2008 and 2014 Senate elections, while Visual 5 looks at the percentage change in votes per party. The mountain counties, Metro Denver, and the southern majority-Latino counties saw significant drops in turnout. The middle's turnout drop is notable considering the rapid population growth that has occurred in Denver in the last decade. Meanwhile, the high plains counties had the lowest declines in total turnout, although this did not translate into the western slope counties along the Utah border that are culturally-similar. 

     Visual 4: County-Level Changes in County-Level Turnout 

     Data Sources: "2014 Abstract," "Official Publication"

     Change in Votes by Party: Visual 5 probably reveals the largest reasons behind Udall's 2014 loss, which was the across-the-board decline in total votes for the Democratic candidate. The massive decline on the High Plains and on the Western Slope bordering Utah significantly stand out, which were also locations where the percent change in Republican votes between 2008 and 2014 was positive. Meanwhile, Metro Denver counties saw greater loss of raw Democratic votes than Republican declines or even gains. Finally, Republican vote gains in Southern Colorado counties mirror the High Plains and Western Slope, where the percent change in Democratic votes was significantly negative as well. An exception to these trends is Boulder and the Mountain counties, where the percent change in Democratic votes were similar or lower than change in Republican ones. 

     Visual 5: 2008-2014 % Difference in Candidate Vote Shift (DEM-REP)

     Note: Say that Democratic candidate Y receives 3 in 2008 and 2 in 2014 while Republican candidate X receives 5 votes in 2008 and 10 in 2014. Since the change in Democratic is -33% and Republican votes is 50%, the percentage difference is -0.88. 

     Data Sources: "2014 Abstract," "Official Publication"

Conclusion: The above visuals and analysis tells a story of why and how Senator Gardner pulled off a since-unprecedented victory in an increasingly-blue state. In particular, the across-the-board drop in Democratic turnout, a significant pro-Republican surge in non-major urban counties, and Gardner's performance in the Metro Denver suburbs doomed Senator Udall's aspirations for another term. These factors are in addition to the general political environment in 2014, classic turnout declines that occur during midterms, and a conservative backlash to President Obama, who was unpopular going into Election Day (Judis). In Colorado specifically, other reasons for the Republican Senate victory include Gardner moderating on some issues to attract independent votes, Udall spending too much time attacking these same positions, poor turnout, and Democratic underperformance among Latino voters, a critical electoral bloc in Colorado (Judis; Sarlin)

Not within a week of Election Day 2018, national and state Democratic talk had set their sights on Senator Gardner, motivated in part by the party's massive gains in Colorado a week prior (Garcia). Prior to the 2018 midterms, polls conducted six months into President Trump's tenure in the White House showed Senator Gardner's disapproval rating above 50% and him losing by double-digits to a "generic Democrat" in 2020 ("Colorado," 1). Meanwhile, the Senator began to walk a tightrope between chairing the Republican Senate Campaign Committee while working closely with Senate Democrats on shared issues (Everett), potentially a sign that the Senator knew what was coming. As the 2020 election cycle moved closer and closer, Gardner was considered a near-certain loser due to him representing an increasingly-blue state with demographics unfavorable to Donald Trump's Republican Party (Garcia). On Election Day, he faced popular ex-Governor John Hickenlooper (D), who won a 9% victory over the incumbent Senator ("Colorado Senate"; Riccardi). While creating the 2010-2020 double-digit Congressional losers post in May, I was surprised to find that Gardner did not lose by double-digits, despite Joe Biden (D) winning the state by 14% (Navarro)! Ultimately, Gardner's 2014 victory represented a temporary deviation in a state that has otherwise been moving in the opposite direction due to 2014's unique electoral conditions detailed here, especially lower Democratic turnout.  

Election Data Sources:

"2014 Abstract of Votes Cast." Office of the Secretary of State of Colorado, www.sos.state.co.us/pubs/elections/Results/Abstract/pdf/2000-2099/2014AbstractBook.pdf. Accessed 4 Jun. 2021. 

"Official Publication of the Abstract of Votes Cast for the 2008 Primary 2008 General." Colorado Secretary of State, www.sos.state.co.us/pubs/elections/Results/Abstract/pdf/2000-2099/2008AbstractBook.pdf. Accessed 4 Jun. 2021. 

Works Cited: 

Camron, Victoria A.F. "Weld County voters like Colorado, reject secessionist proposal." Weld County Times-Call, 5 Nov. 2013, www.timescall.com/2013/11/05/weld-county-voters-like-colorado-reject-secessionist-proposal/. Accessed 11 Jul. 2021. 

"Colorado Senate Election Results." Politico, last updated 6 Jan. 2021, www.politico.com/2020-election/results/colorado/senate/. Accessed 10 Jun. 2021. 

"Colorado Survey Results." Public Policy Polling, 2017, static.politico.com/60/b7/f84038254e46a02a95b7fcf8803c/ppp-save-my-care-poll-of-colorado.pdf. Accessed 4 Jun. 2021. 

"Democrat wins in Colorado Senate race." Reuters, 4 Nov. 2008, www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-colorado-senate/democrat-wins-in-colorado-senate-race-idUSTRE4A42EJ20081105. Accessed 11 Jul. 2021. 

"Election Results 2013: Gov. Christie And More." CNN, 6 Nov. 2013, earlystart.blogs.cnn.com/2013/11/06/election-results-2013-gov-christie-and-more/. Accessed 11 Jul. 2021. 

Everett, Burgess. "'He's a brave man': The lonely existence of Cory Gardner." Politico, 5 Mar. 2021, www.politico.com/story/2018/03/05/cory-gardner-colorado-senate-republicans-433563. Accessed 4 Jun. 2021. 

Frank, John, and Carrie Osgood. "Colorado continues to shift blue: The 2020 election, explained in graphics." Colorado Sun, 10 Nov. 2020, coloradosun.com/2020/11/10/colorado-2020-election-explained/. Accessed 11 Jun. 2021. 

Garcia, Nic. "Which Democrat will challenge U.S. Sen. Cory Gardner? Four names sit on top of insiders’ lists.." The Denver Post, 14 Nov. 2018, https://www.denverpost.com/2018/11/14/cory-gardner-senate-re-election-democratic-challengers/. Accessed 4 Jun. 2021. 

Kondik, Kyle. "Senate 2016: The Republicans’ 2012 Homework." Sabato's Crystal Ball, 11 Dec. 2014, centerforpolitics.org/crystalball/articles/senate-2016-the-republicans-2012-homework/. Accessed 16 Jun. 2021. 

Judis, John B. "Here's Why the Democrats Got Crushed—and Why 2016 Won't Be a Cakewalk." The New Republic, 4 Nov. 2014, newrepublic.com/article/120138/2014-election-results-heres-why-democrats-lost-senate-gop. Accessed 11 Jul. 2021. 

Markus, Ben. "JeffCo Voters A Critical Voting Bloc For Presidential Elections." Colorado Public Radio, 12 Jul. 2016, www.cpr.org/2016/07/12/jeffco-voters-a-critical-voting-bloc-for-presidential-elections/. Accessed 11 Jul. 2021. 

Navarro, Natalia V. "Joe Biden Is On Track To Win Colorado By The Largest Margin Of A Presidential Candidate In Decades." Colorado Public Radio, 5 Nov. 2020, www.cpr.org/2020/11/05/joe-biden-is-on-track-to-win-colorado-by-the-largest-margin-of-a-presidential-candidate-in-decades/. Accessed 10 Jul. 2021. 

Riccardi, Nicholas. "Democrat Hickenlooper wins US Senate race in Colorado." Associated Press, 4 Nov. 2020, apnews.com/article/election-2020-donald-trump-senate-elections-colorado-elections-f5035cf416f2a5243b226cc6c169c2e1. Accessed 12 Jun. 2021. 

Sarlin, Benjy. "Cory Gardner defeats Mark Udall in critical Colorado Senate race." MSNBC News, 4 Nov. 2014, www.msnbc.com/msnbc/cory-gardner-defeats-mark-udall-critical-colorado-senate-race-msna451396. Accessed 10 Jul. 2021. 

Sullivan, Robert David. "How the red and blue map evolved over the past century." America: The Jesuit Review, 29 Jun. 2016, www.americamagazine.org/content/unconventional-wisdom/how-red-and-blue-map-evolved-over-past-century. Accessed 11 Jul. 2021.  

Tomasic, John. "In Senate run, Gardner may be hard-pressed to sell far-right record." The Colorado Independent, 27 Feb. 2014, www.coloradoindependent.com/2014/02/27/in-senate-run-gardner-may-be-hard-pressed-to-sell-far-right-record/. Accessed 16 Jun. 2021. 

Webb, Thomas. "Local 2020 drilling activity lowest in decades." The Daily Sentinel, 18 Feb. 2021, www.gjsentinel.com/news/western_colorado/local-2020-drilling-activity-lowest-in-decades/article_9978a15c-7141-11eb-bcb2-5370ee974e46.html. Accessed 11 Jul. 2021. 

May 16, 2021

Congressional Incumbents Who Lost by Double-Digits from 2010-2020

5/17/2021 UPDATE: After initial publication of this article on 5/16/2021, I noticed that I neglected to include instances from the 2010, 2012, and 2014 elections where three House incumbents lost by double-digits. As of 6:45pm PST on 5/17/2021, I corrected Visual 1, Table 1, and the writing below to account for this. I also changed some of the notes below Visual 1 and Table 1. 

April 11, 2021

Ten Post-2010: Perennial Competitive Congressional Districts

Ten Post-2010: Perennial Competitive Congressional Districts

Introduction: With 2020's Federal elections receding in the rearview mirror, and Congressional redistricting around the corner, a full slate of election results from the post-2012 redistricting period (although a few states had to redistrict mid-decade) allows for understanding of Congressional election trends in the last decade. During each cycle, party institutions determine which House seats on the other side to be targeted, which is often determined by past Congressional and Presidential results in each district (Akin; Kendall). While the exact slates of competitive districts often vary depending on each cycle's political climate, there have been some districts that have remained consistently competitive since the post-2012 redistricting. Today's post will discuss 10 of these districts and their 2012-2020 electoral history. 

Methodology: While I chose not to solely use quantitative election results alone to determine which districts were included here, I tried to choose districts that generally met at least 3 of the 4 conditions listed below: 
  • House race margin was under 10% for at 4 or 5 of the 5 elections post-2010 (2012, 2014, 2016, 2018, 2020).
  • Was extensively-targeted by the opposing party in at least 3 of the 5 elections, and/or was considered by major election predictors (e.g. Sabato's Crystal Ball, FiveThirtyEight, CNN, etc.) to be less than "Safe" or "Solid" for the incumbent or party. 
  • Flipped parties at least once from 2012-2020, and preferably more than once. 
  • Election results generally moved with the "electoral tide" per cycle. Note that of the Congressional elections mentioned above, 2012 was a relatively neutral year, 2014 was a Republican wave, 2016 was a Republican-leaning year, 2018 was a Democratic wave, and 2020 was a neutral-Republican-leaning year. Also keep the corresponding presidential results in mind: Obama's solid re-election in 2012, Trump's narrow upset victory in 2016, and Biden's narrow victory in 2020. 
A Look at the 10 Chosen House Districts: 

Table 1: District Election Results, 2012-2020

Notes: Each colored box refers to the winning party per election, while the number refers to the percent margin between the winner and the second-place candidate. All races featured here had either a Democrat or Republican in the top two positions, with the exception of CA-25's 2014 election, which had two Republicans running in the general election. Election data sources are listed near the bottom of this page, just above "Works Cited." 

     Visual 1: AZ-1 Map

     Image Source: "File:Arizona US Congressional District 1 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 15 May 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Arizona_US_Congressional_District_1_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 
     
     AZ-1 (Flagstaff, Sedona, Navajo Nation, Hopi Nation): While this is the only district on this list that was won by the same party in all five post-2010 House elections, it is included because of its perennial competitiveness. Despite Mitt Romney winning the district in 2012, ex-Rep. Ann Kirkpatrick (D) made a successful comeback that year, followed-up by surviving the 2014 "Red Surge" despite Republican attempts to unseat her (Mutnick). In 2016, Kirkpatrick decided to take on Sen. John McCain (R), leaving Sedona Councilmember Tom o'Halleran (D) to win the seat by around 7% in 2016 and 2018 (Hansen, "Democrat Tom"). Kirkpatrick eventually made another Congressional comeback in 2018, this time in neighboring AZ-2; she recently announced that she would retire for good in 2022 (Mutnick). Despite Biden finally flipping the district blue in 2020, Rep. o'Halleran came out with a narrow 3% victory, further cementing the district's competitive nature (Hansen, "Rep. Tom"). 

     Visual 2: CA-25 Map

     Image Source: "File:California US Congressional District 25 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 21 Mar. 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:California_US_Congressional_District_25_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

     CA-25 (Northern LA suburbs, Palmdale): Encompassing a rapidly-growing suburban area north of Los Angeles, and containing Six Flags Magic Mountain (home to the most roller coasters for any theme park worldwide), CA-25's electoral history is unique due to having 6 elections this decade (5 regular and a special). Longtime incumbent Rep. Buck McKeon (R), then the House Armed Forces Committee chair, won another term in 2012 and decided to make it his last (Felde). The following election saw two Republicans make it out of the "Jungle Primary" to the general election, with Steve Knight (R) winning against Ted Strickland (R). Rep. Knight survived 2016 despite extensive Democratic targeting, even as Hillary Clinton (D) won CA-25 by 7% (Bowman, "Rep. Steve"). In a dramatic reversal two years later, Katie Hill (D) unseated Knight by a similar margin the latter had won by in 2016, and quickly became a rising star (Blood; Modesti). However, Rep. Hill was not even a year into her first term when a major scandal emerged regarding alleged affairs with an office staffer and a campaign official (Blood). After Rep. Hill resigned in late 2019, a special election was called for and held in March 2020, with a runoff planned for May if necessary (Denkmann). Democrat Christy Smith and Republican Mike Garcia both made it to the runoff out of a crowded primary field (which also included Knight and progressive journalist Cenk Uyger) for both the special and regular elections (Zhou). In the low-turnout May runoff, Garcia won the district and prepared to rematch Smith in November for a full-term (Kilgore). When November came, Garcia ended up narrowly winning a full term after several weeks of contentious ballot counting (Kisken). Along with IA-2 and NY-22, CA-25 ended up being won by a Republican with less than a 500 vote margin, making it one of the closest House election results that year ("House Election Results 2020"). 

     Visual 3: Map of FL-26

     Note: The image above shows the pre-2016 district lines. The post-2016 redistricted version of the district is relatively similar, but I was not able to find a copyright-free map or one only requiring attribution to use. 

     Image Source: "File:Florida US Congressional District 26 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 15 Mar. 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Florida_US_Congressional_District_26_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

     FL-26 (Homestead, Florida Keys): Being one of three majority-Cuban-American districts in South Florida (Singer, "Trump's gains"), FL-26 is the only House district on this list that was won by Obama and Clinton by double-digits while being more competitive downballot. In 2012, Joe Garcia (D) won the seat, only to lose narrowly to Carlos Curbelo (R) in the 2014 red wave. Garcia's attempt for a comeback failed in 2016, with the relatively-moderate Curbelo winning by double-digits (Buzzacco-Foerster; Flom). However, Curbelo's luck ran out in 2018, as he narrowly lost re-election to Debbie Muscarsel-Powell (D), despite heavily overperforming Trump's 2016 margin in the district, as seen on Table 1 above ("Carlos"). Yet, Rep. Muscarsel-Powell's luck was also short-lived, as she was one of the main Democrats targeted by the GOP in 2020. That Fall, Democratic concern began to grow over her 2020 election prospects due to suggestions of higher Cuban-American support for Trump relative to 2016 (Higgins). Despite Democratic optimism that she would survive, Rep. Muscarsel-Powell narrowly lost to Miami-Dade County Mayor Carlos Giménez (R) as Trump rolled to a second victory in Florida largely off the back of intense energy among Cuban-American voters in Miami-Dade (Martinez). 

     Visual 4: Map of IA-1

     Image Source: "File:Iowa US Congressional District 1 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 15 May 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Iowa_US_Congressional_District_1_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

     IA-1 (NE Iowa; Cedar Rapids, Dubuque, Waterloo): While Iowa has seen a significant pro-Republican trend in the Trump era, it also still seems to have a propensity to swing depending on the tide. Northeast Iowa's IA-1 almost perfectly summarizes the state's recent electoral history, having voted for Barack Obama by double-digits before being won by Trump twice (DiGiacomo) (Table 1). The decade started off with incumbent Rep. Bruce Braley (D) holding the seat, who vacated it to (unsuccessfully) run for Iowa's Class 2 Senate seat in 2014 ("AP: Rod Blum"). Rod Blum won the seat that year, and fended off Democratic attempts to unseat him in 2016 (Crippes), likely being buoyed by Trump's unexpectly good showing in Iowa. Around this time, he allegedly founded a business while serving in Congress, and neglected to properly report it, which caused him to be investigated by the House Ethics Committee (Foley). During the 2018 cycle, Blum was one of the most high-profile Democratic targets due to this scandal and the Democratic recruit, 28-year old state legislator Abby Finkenauer (D) (DiGiacomo; Foley). On Election Day, IA-1 seemed to continue its destiny of "going with the national tide" as Finkenauer (D) won the seat over Blum (DiGiacomo). Despite being favored for a second term, Rep. Finkenauer lost to local TV reporter Ashley Hinson (R) as Trump overperformed expectations in the Buckeye State (and nationally) once again (Miller; Pearce).  

     Visual 5: Map of NE-2

     Image Source: "File:Nebraska US Congressional District 2 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 15 May 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Nebraska_US_Congressional_District_2_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

     NE-2 (Omaha and suburbs): To some extent, NE-2 is almost a reverse of NH-1 and NV-4 (both discussed below). In 2012, incumbent Rep. Lee Terry (R) won a close victory in the district that is more-watched during presidential elections (as Nebraska allocates its 3 non-statewide votes by the winner of each of its 3 Congressional districts) (Livingston). Fast-forward a year, and Rep. Terry got into hot water after making comments deemed insensitive and unemphatic towards those affected by the 2013 government shutdown, although he soon apologized (Reilly). In an exception to the 2014 Red Wave, Terry narrowly lost to Democrat Brad Ashford (D), becoming one of two Republican House incumbents to lose that year. The other was FL-2 Rep. Steve Southerland (R), who also faced a good Democratic challenger and also made a major mistake by attending a fundraiser restricted only to men (Etters). However, Rep. Ashford's dream of a second term came to an end in 2016, as he narrowly lost to Don Bacon (R), despite Democratic hopes that Clinton would win NE-2's electoral vote (which she did not) ("Bacon"). National Democrats extensively targeted the district in both 2018 and 2020, which saw progressive Kara Eastman (D) win both primaries over Ashford and Ashford's wife Ann, respectively. As noted previously on this blog, Eastman's 2018 campaign nearly won the seat despite being abandoned by Democratic Party campaign institutions under the belief she was too liberal for the district (Gronewold). By contrast, her 2020 campaign tried to reach to a broader audience, although some intra-party antagonism continued, with Ann Ashford refusing to endorse her (Jordan), and prominent progressive Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D) blasting Democratic campaign institutions for not showing enough support for her (Panetta). Yet, national Democratic-aligned institutions extensively supported Eastman's 2020 campaign, which Rep. Bacon argued was proof that she was ideologically out-of-touch with the district (Axelrod, "Bacon"; Panetta). Despite this energy at her back, Eastman failed to win the district, losing to Bacon by 4% even as Joe Biden won back the district's electoral vote (Matherny). 

     Visual 6: Map of NV-3

     Image Source: "File:Nevada US Congressional District 3 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 15 May 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Nevada_US_Congressional_District_3_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

     NV-3 (Southern Las Vegas suburbs, Henderson, Boulder City): NV-3 did not start the decade as competitive, but moved that way after incumbent Rep. Joe Heck (R) decided to (unsuccessfully) vie for then-Democratic Majority Leader Harry Reid (who was retiring)'s Senate seat in 2016 ("Nevada Senate"). That year, Jacky Rosen (D) narrowly flipped NV-3 blue in an expensive and close House race against perennial candidate Danny Tarkanian (R) (Rindels, "Joy"). Before even reaching year 1 of her time in the House, Rep. Rosen proceeded to seek Nevada's other Senate seat in 2018, which she eventually won (Dixon). After her departure, she was replaced by now-Rep. Susie Lee (D), who was also running against Tarkanian (Price). Simultaneously with Biden narrowly flipped the district blue after it voted for Obama and Trump in 2012 and 2016, respectively, Rep. Lee won a narrow victory for a second term (Emerson; Lochhead). 

    Visual 7: Map of NV-4

    Image Source: "File:Nevada US Congressional District 4 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 15 May 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Nevada_US_Congressional_District_4_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

     NV-4 (Northern Las Vegas suburbs, Ely, Tonopah): Located just north of NV-3, and containing Area 51 (subject of the popular 2019 joke "raid"), NV-4's split suburban/rural geography has witnessed close results in almost every election since 2012. That year, the district was won by Steven Horsford (D), who had been Nevada's first Black State Senate Leader, and faced none other than Danny Tarkanian (R) (Rindels, "Former"). Two years later, Rep. Horsford was unseated by Crescent Hardy (R) in an upset mainly caused by significantly diminished margins in Las Vegas's portion of the district (Phillips). Hardy also served one term before losing to Democratic rising star Ruben Kihuen (D) two years later. However, Rep. Kihuen's ambitions to build a Congressional career were halted when he faced accusations of sexual harassment a year later, which forced him to not run in 2018 (Snyder). A year later, Hardy and Horsford won their respective primaries to rematch, and Horsford claimed a second victory by nearly-double digits that November (Axelrod, "Rep. Steven"). He followed-this up with a narrow victory in 2020, thus finally netting a second consecutive term (Emerson). 

     Visual 8: Map of NH-1

     Image Source: "File:New Hampshire US Congressional District 1 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 15 May 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:New_Hampshire_US_Congressional_District_1_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

     NH-1 (Dover, Manchester, Portsmouth): Of the districts profiled here, NH-1 arguably best fits the textbook definition of "perennial competitive Congressional district," even when considering the similar pre-2012 version. Since 2006, the district has flipped parties a total of five times (2006, 2010, 2012, 2014, 2016), with the last four featuring Democrat Carol Shea-Porter and Republican Frank Guinta facing off each time. After her third non-consecutive victory in 2016, Rep. Shea-Porter decided to quit Congress in 2018 (Carosa and DiStato). Manchester Executive Chris Pappas (D) won by 8% in 2018 and followed-up with a narrower 5% in 2020, who is projected to be targeted in redistricting by state Republicans (Steinhauser). 

     Visual 9: Map of TX-23

     Image Source: "File:Texas US Congressional District 23 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 28 Mar. 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Texas_US_Congressional_District_23_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

     TX-23 (western RGV, suburban San Antonio): No discussion of perennial competitive House districts is complete without mentioning majority-Latino TX-23, the only Congressional district that voted Romney-Clinton-Biden in the last three presidential elections (Singer, "Texas"). It is the only district mentioned here whose Congressional result was under 5% for the last four elections, and for 2 consecutive elections, under 1% (Table 1). After Republicans flipped the (similar) pre-2010 version with Quico Canseco (R) in 2010, local state representative Pete Gallego (D) took it back in 2012, despite Romney narrowly winning the district (Aaronson and Hamilton). Like several other Democrats on this list who won in 2012, the red wave of 2014 doomed Rep. Gallego in his contest with ex-CIA Officer and moderate Republican Will Hurd. In 2016, Rep. Hurd followed up 2014 with a narrow reelection victory in 2016 despite extensive Democratic attempts to unseat him (Livingston and Luiz). During his tenure, Rep. Hurd solidified his reputation as a moderate Republican, which included frequent criticism of President Trump's policies and statements, especially related to immigration. However, this didn't prevent him from pulling off a third consecutive hair-thin victory against Democrat Gina Ortiz Jones, who did not concede until all provisional and military ballots were counted, and who was accidently prematurely projected the winner by multiple outlets (Barragán). Sensing 2020 to potentially be another difficult year, Hurd chose not to run again, with that year's nominated Republican being ex-Army Officer Tony Gonzalez. Despite Ortiz Jones running again and being favored to win, she lost to Gonzalez in a major upset, who overperformed Trump in the district (Narea). 

     Visual 10: Map of UT-4

     Image Source: "File:Utah US Congressional District 4 (since 2013).tif." Wikimedia Commons, 15 May 2014, commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Utah_US_Congressional_District_4_(since_2013).tif. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

     UT-4 (Salt Lake City suburbs): At first glance, it seems surprising that UT-4 has been a competitive Congressional district for most of the last decade. As shown on Table 1, this largely-suburban district voted heavily in favor of Mitt Romney (R) in 2012, and voted heavily for Trump both times despite the district swinging left. Yet, even as Mitt Romney won the state identifying with his religion, UT-4 narrowly re-elected Rep. Jim Matheson (D), member of a famed Utah political family (Camia). Matheson retired in 2014, and despite the district's heavy Republican lean, Republican Mia Love (who ran in 2012 against Matheson) only won the district narrowly (Gildea). Rep. Love secured another term in 2016 before narrowly losing in 2018 to Salt Lake County Mayor Ben McAdams (D) (Davidson). However, Rep. McAdams failed to obtain a second term in 2020, being narrowly defeated by ex-NFL player Burgess Owens (R). Other than UT-4's recent electoral history, what makes this district notable is that it has featured a Black Republican nominee in each election since the 2012 redistricting. Mia Love was the first Haitian-American elected to the House, the first female Black Republican, and the first Black House member from Utah. Rep. Owens is the second to achieve the latter (Roche).  

Runner-Ups: In addition to the ten above, I considered the following districts that featured close or competitive results multiple times post-2010, but excluded because I wanted to keep the total number at 10, and because I felt didn't fit as well with the established criteria. In particular, some of these districts started off as competitive or not, but receded to the opposite as time went on, especially in the post-2016 environment. 
  • CA-7
  • CA-10 (I almost used this one instead of CA-25)
  • CO-6
  • IL-10
  • IL-13
  • ME-2
  • MN-1
  • MN-2
  • NC-8 (was redrawn mid-decade)
  • NY-22
  • VA-2 (was redrawn mid-decade)
Conclusion: The post-2012 Congressional elections have seen significant upheaval and change on the House map, with most of the remaining Democratic seats in rural White territory withering away and many longtime Republican suburban and urban seats becoming more competitive or flipping blue. Many of these seats have become relatively uncompetitive since changing sides, and will likely continue unless another big change occurs. Yet, in between these two trends, some districts have remained consistently competitive throughout the last decade, including multiple that have flipped parties multiple times within that time period. While most also featured close presidential results by either party in the concurrent or preceding presidential election, there are some notable exceptions, including FL-26 and UT-4. With another round of national redistricting around the corner, some of the current districts will generally remain the same,  but new ones will be created, and others will be eliminated altogether. As a result, while some of the districts (or their post-2020 version) might remain competitive going into the middle of the decade, others will emerge depending on redistricting or changes in electoral geography. 

Election Data Sources: 

Haas, Karen H. "Statistics of the Presidential and Congressional Election of November 6, 2012." Clerk of the United States House of Representatives, 28 Feb. 2013, history.house.gov/Institution/Election-Statistics/Election-Statistics/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

---. "Statistics of the Presidential and Congressional Election of November 4, 2014." Clerk of the United States House of Representatives, 9 Mar. 2015, history.house.gov/Institution/Election-Statistics/Election-Statistics/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

---. "Statistics of the Presidential and Congressional Election of November 8, 2016." Clerk of the United States House of Representatives, 27 Feb. 2017, history.house.gov/Institution/Election-Statistics/2016election/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

"House Election Results 2020." CNN, www.cnn.com/election/2020/results/house. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Johnson, Cheryl. "Statistics of the Presidential and Congressional Election of November 6, 2016." Clerk of the United States House of Representatives, 28 Feb. 2019, history.house.gov/Institution/Election-Statistics/2018election/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Nir, David. "Daily Kos Elections' presidential results by congressional district for 2020, 2016, and 2012." Daily Kos, 19 Nov. 2020, www.dailykos.com/stories/2020/11/19/1163009/-Daily-Kos-Elections-presidential-results-by-congressional-district-for-2020-2016-and-2012. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Works Cited: 

Aaronson, Becca, and Reeve Hamilton. "Congressional Roundup: In Narrow, Pricey Defeat, Gallego Ousts Canseco." Texas Tribune, 7 Nov. 2012, www.texastribune.org/2012/11/07/congressional-round-gallego-closely-defeats-cansec/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Akin, Stephanie. "These 47 House Democrats are on the GOP’s target list for 2022." Roll Call, 10 Feb. 2021, www.rollcall.com/2021/02/10/these-47-house-democrats-are-on-the-gops-target-list-for-2022/. Accessed 11 Apr. 2021. 

"AP: Rod Blum winner of Iowa US House 1 race." KCCI8, 4 Nov. 2014, www.kcci.com/article/ap-rod-blum-winner-of-iowa-us-house-1-race/6899033#. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Axelrod, Tad. "Bacon wins key Nebraska House race." The Hill, 4 Nov. 2020, thehill.com/homenews/campaign/523491-bacon-wins-key-nebraska-house-race. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

---. "Rep. Steven Horsford wins Democratic House primary in Nevada." The Hill, 10 Jun. 2020, thehill.com/homenews/502028-rep-steven-horsford-wins-democratic-house-primary-in-nevada. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

"Bacon wins Nebraska House seat after Ashford concedes." Politico, 9 Nov. 2016, www.politico.com/story/2016/11/don-bacon-beats-brad-ashford-231105. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021.

Barragán, James. "Gina Ortiz Jones concedes to Will Hurd in race for Texas' most competitive congressional district." The Dallas Morning News, 19 Nov. 2018, www.dallasnews.com/news/2018/11/19/gina-ortiz-jones-concedes-to-will-hurd-in-race-for-texas-most-competitive-congressional-district/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Blood, Michael. "Scandal brings election risk for rising Democratic star." Associated Press, 26 Oct. 2019, apnews.com/article/dd03694625f845349b4c2984330eadbd. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Bowman, Bridget. "GOP Poll Shows Close Race for Rod Blum in Iowa’s 1st District." Roll Call, 16 Oct. 2018, www.rollcall.com/2018/10/16/gop-poll-shows-close-race-for-rod-blum-in-iowas-1st-district/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

---. "Rep. Steve Knight: The Most Vulnerable Republican in California?." Roll Call, 31 May 2018, www.rollcall.com/2018/05/31/rep-steve-knight-the-most-vulnerable-republican-in-california/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Buzzacco-Foerster, Jenna. "Carlos Curbelo wins a second term in CD 26." Florida Politics, 8 Nov. 2016, floridapolitics.com/archives/226757-carlos-curbelo-wins-second-term-cd-26/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Camia, Catalina. "Democratic Rep. Jim Matheson won't seek new term." Politico, 17 Dec. 2013, www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2013/12/17/jim-matheson-congress-retire-utah-blue-dog/4062943/. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

"Carlos Curbelo Loses District 26 In Tightly Contested House Race." WLRN, 6 Nov. 2018, www.wlrn.org/news/2018-11-06/carlos-curbelo-loses-district-26-in-tightly-contested-house-race. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Carosa, Kristen, and John DiStaso. "Updated: Shea-Porter says she won’t seek re-election in 2018, but 'not retiring'." WMUR, 6 Oct. 2017, www.wmur.com/article/surprise-announcement-shea-porter-says-she-wont-run-for-re-election-in-2018/12796248. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Crippes, Christiania. "Blum wins 1st District race as Vernon concedes." The Gazette, 9 Nov. 2016, www.thegazette.com/campaigns-elections/blum-wins-1st-district-race-as-vernon-concedes/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Davidson, Lee. "It’s over. Democrat Ben McAdams ousts Republican Rep. Mia Love by 694 votes." Salt Lake Tribune, 20 Nov. 2018, www.sltrib.com/news/politics/2018/11/20/its-over-democrat-ben/. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Denkmann, Libby. "CA-25 Special Election: Who Will Represent This District During The Coronavirus Pandemic And Recovery?." LAist, 23 Apr. 2020, laist.com/2020/04/23/ca-25-special-election-congressional-district-coronavirus-pandemi.php. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

DiGiacomo, Julia. "Abby Finkenauer unseats Republican Rod Blum in Iowa’s 1st District." The Daily Iowan, 6 Nov. 2018, dailyiowan.com/2018/11/06/abby-finkenauer-unseats-republican-rod-blum-in-iowas-1st-district/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Dixon, Darius. "Jacky Rosen unseats Dean Heller in Nevada Senate race." Politico, 7 Nov. 2018, www.politico.com/story/2018/11/07/jacky-rosen-vs-dean-heller-nevada-senate-race-results-2018-963523. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Emerson, Justin. "Nevada Democrat Steven Horsford reelected to U.S. House." Las Vegas Sun, 6 Nov. 2020, lasvegassun.com/news/2020/nov/06/democrats-horsford-lee-leading-in-nevada-house-rac/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Etters, Karl. "Gwen Graham defeats Steve Southerland." Tallahassee Democrat, 5 Nov. 2014, www.tallahassee.com/story/news/local/state/2014/11/04/thirty-percent-of-congressional-district-voters-have-cast-ballots/18452597/. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Felde, Kitty. "GOP Rep. ‘Buck’ McKeon of Santa Clarita to step down after 11 terms." 89.3KPCC, 15 Jan. 2014, www.scpr.org/blogs/politics/2014/01/15/15613/buck-mckeon-set-to-step-down-after-11-terms/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Flom, Christina. "Republican Carlos Curbelo Re-Elected in Florida’s 26th District." Roll Call, 8 Nov. 2016, www.rollcall.com/2016/11/08/republican-carlos-curbelo-re-elected-in-floridas-26th-district/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Foley, Ryan. "House Ethics Committee investigating Iowa Rep. Rod Blum." Associated Press, 4 Sept. 2018, apnews.com/article/faac7334ea554b9db652704982312525. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Gildea, Terry. "First Black Republican Congresswoman Wants To Be Known For More." National Public Radio, 30 Dec. 2014, www.npr.org/2014/12/30/374033033/first-black-republican-congresswoman-wants-to-be-known-for-more. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Gronewold, Anna. "Fed Up in Flyover Country." Politico, 2 Oct. 2020, www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/10/02/trump-republicans-nebraska-nice-420691. Accessed 4 Oct. 2020. 

Hansen, Ronald. "Democrat Tom O'Halleran captures 1st Congressional District; GOP maintains majority." Arizona Central, 8 Nov. 2016, www.azcentral.com/story/news/politics/elections/2016/11/08/arizona-congressional-district-election-results-babeu-ohalleran/92894480/. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

---. "Rep. Tom O'Halleran wins a third term; all of Arizona's US House incumbents reelected." AZCentral, 10 Nov. 2020, www.azcentral.com/story/news/politics/arizona/2020/11/10/rep-tom-ohalleran-defeats-tiffany-shedd-win-third-term/6215675002/. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Higgins, Tucker. "Republicans hope Cubans, warming to Trump, will deliver them Democrats’ most vulnerable Florida House seat." NBC News, 30 Oct. 2020, www.cnbc.com/2020/10/30/florida-house-race-debbie-mucarsel-powell-carlos-gimenez-in-tight-race.html. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Jordan, Joe. "Ann Ashford Won't Endorse Eastman." News Channel Nebraska Central, 24 Aug. 2020, www.newschannelnebraska.com/story/42534880/ann-ashford-wont-endorse-eastman-does-she-want-eastman-to-lose-and-what-about-those-campaign-files. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Kendall, Karson. "House Democrats to target 22 districts in next year's midterms." ABC News, 6 Apr. 2021, abcnews.go.com/Politics/house-democrats-target-22-districts-years-midterms/story?id=76900315. Accessed 11 Apr. 2021. 

Kilgore, Ed. "How Did Republicans Win a Special Congressional Election in California?." Intelligencer, The New Yorker Magazine, 18 May 2020, nymag.com/intelligencer/2020/05/how-did-republicans-win-a-california-congressional-election.html. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Kisken, Tom. "25th Congressional District results: Republican Mike Garcia beats Dem Christy Smith." Ventura County Star, 30 Nov. 2020, www.vcstar.com/story/news/local/2020/11/30/california-25th-district-mike-garcia-election-results-christy-smith/6456657002/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Livingston, Abby. "Lee Terry’s Seat Gives Republicans Heartburn in Nebraska." Roll Call, 29 May 2014, www.rollcall.com/2014/05/29/lee-terrys-seat-gives-republicans-heartburn-in-nebraska/. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Livingston, Abby, and Elena Meija Lutz. "U.S. Rep. Will Hurd victorious in rematch with Pete Gallego." Texas Tribune, 8 Nov. 2016, www.texastribune.org/2016/11/08/texas-23rd-congressional-district-results/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Lochhead, Colton. "Lee wins re-election, other races still tight." Las Vegas Review-Journal, www.reviewjournal.com/news/politics-and-government/nevada/lee-wins-re-election-other-races-still-tight-2178901/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Martinez, Alexandra. "How Democrats can win back the Cuban-American vote." CNN, 27 Nov. 2020, www.cnn.com/2020/11/27/opinions/how-democrats-can-win-back-the-cuban-american-vote-alexandra-martinez/index.html. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Matheny, Ryan. "Bacon wins rematch with Eastman in Nebraska's 2nd District." KMALand, 4 Nov. 2020, www.kmaland.com/news/bacon-wins-rematch-with-eastman-in-nebraskas-2nd-district/article_208c7a60-1e72-11eb-9841-43cd243105f9.html. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Miller, Ryan. "The polls were wrong – sorta. But is it too soon to 'blow up' the polling industry?" USA Today, 5 Nov. 2020, www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/elections/2020/11/05/polls-underestimated-trump-votes-biden-election-2020/6171284002/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Modesti, Kevin. "Election 2018: Steve Knight concedes; Democrat Katie Hill wins the 25th Congressional District." Los Angeles Daily News, 7 Nov. 2018, www.dailynews.com/2018/11/07/election-2018-steve-hill-concedes-democrat-katie-hill-wins-the-25th-congressional-district/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Mutnick, Ally. "Ann Kirkpatrick announces 1st House retirement of 2022." Politico, 12 Mar. 2021, www.politico.com/news/2021/03/12/ann-kirkpatrick-announces-house-retirement-475512. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Narea, Nicole. "Republican Tony Gonzales has won retiring Rep. Will Hurd’s seat in Texas." Vox, 4 Nov. 2020, www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2020/11/4/21535743/house-results-texas-23-gonzales-ortiz-jones. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021.

"Nevada Senate Election 2016." Electing the Senate: Indirect Democracy Before the 17th Amendment. Brown University, www.brown.edu/research/projects/electing-the-senate/news/2016-08/nevada-senate-election-2016. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021

Panetta, Grace. "LIVE UPDATES: Kara Eastman wins the Democratic primary in Nebraska's second congressional district." Business Insider, 12 May 2020, www.businessinsider.com/nebraska-house-primaries-kara-eastman-vs-ann-ashford-live-results-2020-5. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Pearce, Andrew. "Republican Ashley Hinson beats incumbent Abby Finkenauer in 1st Congressional District race." KWWL7, 3 Nov. 2020, kwwl.com/2020/11/03/republican-ashley-hinson-beats-incumbent-abby-finkenauer-in-1st-congressional-district-race/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Phillips, Amber. "Cresent Hardy closes out surprising win over Rep. Steven Horsford." Las Vegas Sun, 4 Nov. 2014, lasvegassun.com/news/2014/nov/04/cresent-hardy-holds-surprising-lead-rep-steven-hor/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Price, Michelle. "Boosted by activism, Nevada women score big election wins." KOLD13, 8 Nov. 2018, www.kold.com/2018/11/08/boosted-by-activism-nevada-women-score-big-election-wins/. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Reilly, Mollie. "Lee Terry Apologizes For Refusing To Give Up Salary During Shutdown To Pay For His ‘Nice House’." The Huffington Post, 6 Oct. 2013, www.huffpost.com/entry/lee-terry-salary_n_4054283. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021.

Rindels, Michelle. "Former Democratic Rep. Steven Horsford announces run for his old House seat." The Nevada Independent, 25 Jan. 2018, thenevadaindependent.com/article/democratic-former-rep-steven-horsford-announces-run-for-his-old-house-seat. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

---. "Joy and agony after Nevada’s closest, costliest House race." Associated Press, 11 Nov. 2016, apnews.com/article/8fa427f8ed0445b5aa8a49e17c4eb09a. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Roche, Lisa Riley. "Burgess Owens wins back Utah’s 4th Congressional District seat for Republicans." Deseret News, 16 Nov. 2020, www.deseret.com/utah/2020/11/16/21569764/rep-ben-mcadams-is-conceding-to-burgess-owens-in-close-4th-district-race. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Singer, Jeff. "Trump's gains with Latinos were most pronounced in three heavily Cuban districts in South Florida." Daily Kos, 15 Jan. 2021, www.dailykos.com/stories/2021/1/15/2009489/-Trump-s-gains-with-Latinos-were-most-pronounced-in-three-heavily-Cuban-districts-in-South-Florida. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

---. "Texas didn't go as planned for Democrats, but the suburbs still moved sharply away from Republicans." Daily Kos, 14 Jan. 2021, www.dailykos.com/stories/2021/1/14/2009139/-Texas-didn-t-go-as-planned-for-Democrats-but-the-suburbs-still-moved-sharply-away-from-Republicans. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Snyder, Riley. "Dogged by sexual harassment allegations, Ruben Kihuen says he won't run for re-election to Congress." The Nevada Independent, 16 Dec. 2017, thenevadaindependent.com/article/dogged-by-sexual-harassment-allegations-ruben-kihuen-says-he-wont-run-for-reelection-to-congress. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021. 

Steinhauser, Paul. "On the trail: National Republicans target Hassan." Concord Monitor, 26 Mar. 2021, www.concordmonitor.com/on-the-trail-39659543. Accessed 9 Apr. 2021. 

Zhou, Li. "California primary live results." Vox, 5 Mar. 2020, www.vox.com/2020/3/3/21155139/california-primary-live-results-super-tuesday-2020. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021.