Search This Blog

Featured Post

Introduction

Hello all readers, Welcome to The Parmeter Politics and Policy Record ! My name is Nathan Parmeter, an aspiring public policy professional a...

Showing posts with label Social Policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Social Policy. Show all posts

May 30, 2021

The Viability and Limitations of "Vaccine Lotteries"

Author's Notes: After publishing last week's content, I remembered that in early March, I indicated that the results of the 1 post/week pilot program and the decision as to whether it will be permanent would be provided in late April. I've decided to extend the pilot program through June 10th, when I will provide a definite final decision.

Furthermore, the first anniversary of this blog is upcoming! I plan to have a special two-part blog post reflecting on this blog's first year coming out on Thursday, June 10th, which falls on the first anniversary of the Introduction page being published. Note that there will be no normal post coming out the following Sunday, June 13th, 2021, although there will be a normal one next Sunday, June 6th. 

May 09, 2021

Interpreting the April 2021 Jobs Report

Interpreting the April 2021 Jobs Report

Introduction: With vaccination rates increasing and the Coronavirus's daily spread at the lowest levels in months (Rattner), many Covid-related restrictions have been relaxed, thus leading to increased economic optimism (Bartash). On Friday, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (a division of the Department of Labor) released their monthly employment report, something that has received significant attention since (Cox). Today's post will be brief, providing an overview of the report's main findings, and discussion of the results for socio-economic policy. Note that I will not go over every data finding and result from the report, but will focus on the major ones, and significant sub-level results that are significant or otherwise stand out. 

Overview into the April 2021 Jobs Report: 
  • Change in Jobs: Probably one of the most-watched metrics, the report estimated that around 266,000 net jobs (excluding the agricultural sector) were added to the job market in April 2021 ("The Employment Report," 1). 
  • Labor Force Participation: As a quick back-to-basics economics lesson, the unemployment rate is a percentage of those in the labor force, who are defined as those either working ("employed") or unemployed and actively looking for work (Majaski). Out of the eligible labor force population, around 61% of the American population is currently in the labor force, equal to around 156 million Americans. There is little change in the labor force participation rate, which has hovered around 61% since December as well ("The Employment Report," 13). 
    • Unemployment Rate: The estimated unemployment rate in April 2021 was 6.1%, which represents almost no change from the previous month, and minimal change from December 2020, when the unemployment rate was around 6.5% ("The Employment Report," 1). Out of the total labor force, this equates to around 9.8 million Americans out-of-work who are seeking employment ("The Employment Report," 13). 
    • Out of Labor Force: In addition to those in the labor force (unemployed or employed), there is another segment of the American population who is eligible to work and is interested, had searched for work in the last year, but are currently not seeking work (per BLS guidelines, within the last 4 weeks). Per the April report, an estimated 1.9 million workers currently fall into this category, an increase of 419,000 over March. Finally, an estimated 565,000 Americans are considered "discouraged workers," or those claiming that no employment opportunities exist for them, which also increased over the last month ("The Employment Report," 2). 
  • Part-Time Employment: Defined as employment less than 34 hours a week in the United States ("The Employment Report," 21), around 25 million Americans worked part-time in April 2021 (including this article's author). Out of that total, only around 5 million worked part-time for economic reasons, while the vast majority worked part-time for noneconomic reasons (i.e. not because of unfavorable workforce and economic conditions). Compared with March 2021, the number of Americans working part-time for economic reasons declined, while those working part-time for non-economic reasons increased. All of these statistics generally hold true when adjusting for whether one works in an agricultural-related job ("The Employment Report," 21). 
  • Significant Sector-Level Changes: When looking at sector-level employment data, one of the most striking was a significant increase (331,000 new jobs) in hospitality and leisure jobs, which includes restaurants, recreational facilities, and gambling facilities ("The Employment Report," 2). Other than that sector, other sectors did not see significant changes in employment, and some saw decreases. For example, educational services-related jobs saw a slight decline relative to last month, and have yet to bounce back from the massive decline last year. Meanwhile, employment agencies and "temporary help services" have seen gradual declines in total employment, especially relative to the situation one year ago. Finally, at all levels of government (excluding local-level education jobs), total employment remained relatively stagnant despite increasing over the total one year ago. Local-level education jobs are an exception as employment in that sector increased over March ("The Employment Report," 31-33). 
External Implications and Analysis: 
  • Debates over Unemployment Benefits: In the last week, especially with the release of the jobs report, intense partisan debate has ensued over ongoing pandemic-related unemployment benefits. In particular, business groups have expressed concern that the supplemental $300/week unemployment benefits has discouraged unemployed Americans from seeking work (Franck and Schwartz). At the state-level, several states have decreased or seek to decrease such benefits as a means to incentivize unemployed workers to find employment (Iacauri; Luhby). Opponents of these actions have argued that even with increased economic optimism, for the unemployed, searching for work takes time and resources that unemployment benefits can cover (Luhby). Finally, economic analysis has shown that the Coronavirus-caused recession is far different than previous recessions, such as some workers having to recover from the disease, children being stuck at home, and thus requiring parental supervision (discussed further below), low wages in many sectors discouraging workers from applying, and the virus still being a widespread problem (Iacauri). 
  • Continuing Pandemic Closures and Restrictions: While many sectors of the American economy have been reopening, the sector-level results detailed above show how different sectors are bouncing back as the economy reopens. In particular, the massive increase in the hospitality and leisure sector likely reflects expectations for a rebound in tourism and travel this summer as a result of repealed travel restrictions (Kwok). Meanwhile, the slight uptick in education-related jobs is probably a reflection of schools slowly transitioning back to in-person instruction, although like other sectors, the breadth of school reopenings is still low because the vaccine is not yet available for Americans under age 16 (Egan and Strikler; Map: Where"). Finally, the declines in employment agencies and "temporary help agencies," along with public-sector courier and messenger services, could be a reflection on overall economic optimism, with more workers seeking out employment opportunities on their own.  
  • Stagnant Labor Force Participation Rate: As noted above, the labor force participation rate of the total eligible population has remained relatively constant since January, even with increased economic optimism. There are several potential reasons for this. First, as discussed previously on this blog, the pandemic has likely exacerbated the retirement of "Baby Boomers" out of the workforce, many of whom may find it difficult to find new employment if they retire or are laid off (Novack). Second, as explained above, with many primary and secondary schools still not offering in-person or significant in-person instruction, some parents (especially women) have been forced to continue staying home to watch over their children. In conjunction with this, the high cost of child care combined with the pandemic's effects on child care facilities and economic strains have made this situation difficult for parents in this situation. Finally, general concern over the ongoing virus, despite the recent decline in new cases, could be keeping some workers wary of re-entering the labor force at the moment (Iacauri). 
Works Cited: 

Bartash, Jeffrey. "Small businesses grow more optimistic after states lift restrictions — but hiring is a big problem." MarketWatch, 13 Apr. 2021, www.marketwatch.com/story/small-businesses-grow-more-optimistic-after-states-lift-restrictions-but-hiring-is-a-big-problem-11618259877. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

Cox, Jeff. "April’s expected hiring boom goes bust as nonfarm payroll gain falls well short of estimates." CNBC, 7 May 2021, www.cnbc.com/2021/05/07/jobs-report-april-2021.html. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

Davidson, Paul. "Major business group calls for ending $300 federal bonus in unemployment checks, blaming it for weak April job gains." USA Today, 7 May 2021, www.usatoday.com/story/money/2021/05/07/unemployment-check-chamber-commerce-wants-end-300-federal-perk/4990742001/. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

Egan, Lauren, and Laura Strickler. "FDA preparing to authorize Pfizer Covid vaccine for 12- to 15-year-olds as early as next week." NBC News, 4 May 2021. Accessed 9 May 2021. 

Franck, Thomas, Brian Schwartz. "U.S. Chamber of Commerce blames weak jobs report on enhanced unemployment benefit, kicks off lobbying effort." CNBC News, 7 May 2021, www.cnbc.com/2021/05/07/us-chamber-of-commerce-rips-300-jobless-benefit-calls-for-repeal.html. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

Iacurci, Greg. "Montana, South Carolina to kick people off jobless benefits even as unemployment rises." CNBC, 7 May 2021, www.cnbc.com/2021/05/07/montana-south-carolina-ending-participation-in-fed-unemployment-programs.html. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

Kwok, Linchi. "Will the Hospitality and Travel Industry Recover in 2021?" hospitalitynet, 18 Feb. 2021, www.hospitalitynet.org/opinion/4103064.html#:~:text=According%20to%20AHLA's%20report%2C%20hotel,from%20%24167%20billion%20in%202019. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

Luhby, Tami. "Want to keep unemployment benefits? Many states are again requiring a job search." CNN, 7 Apr. 2021, www.cnn.com/2021/04/07/politics/unemployment-job-search-requirement/index.html. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

Majaski, Christina. "Participation Rate vs. Unemployment Rate: What's the Difference?" Investopedia, 27 Jan. 2021, www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/061515/what-key-difference-between-participation-rate-and-unemployment-rate.asp#:~:text=The%20key%20difference%20between%20the,is%20currently%20without%20a%20job. Accessed 9 May 2021. 

"Map: Where Are Schools Required to Be Open?" Education Week, 7 May 2021, www.edweek.org/leadership/map-where-are-schools-closed/2020/07. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

Novack, Janet. "8 Ways Coronavirus Will Drastically Alter Boomer Retirements." Forbes, 16 Mar. 2020, www.forbes.com/sites/janetnovack/2020/03/16/8-ways-coronavirus-will-drastically-alter-boomer-retirements/?sh=53f7ad0c3474. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

Rattner, Nate. "U.S. vaccination pace slides further from peak levels as Covid case counts decline in most states." CNBC, 29 Apr. 2021, www.cnbc.com/2021/04/29/covid-19-cases-deaths-vaccinations-daily-update.html. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

"The Employment Situation - April 2021." United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, 7 May 2021, www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/empsit.pdf. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

"Useful Definitions." Economic Policy Institute, www.epi.org/newsroom/useful_definitions/. Accessed 8 May 2021. 

February 25, 2021

What's in the California COVID relief bill?

What's in the California COVID relief bill? 

Introduction: As of the moment of this blog post's publication, Congress continues to negotiate over the next proposed Federal-level COVID relief bill (Fram). Meanwhile, California Governor Newsom (D) passed a $7.6 million state-level relief package on Tuesday after being approved by the state legislature (Beam). Nicknamed the "Golden State Stimulus, the relief package will provide several forms of direct and indirect assistance to help residents and businesses of California survive the ongoing pandemic, which has caused the disappearance of 1.5 million jobs since last March ("State lawmakers"). Today's post will provide a brief rundown of some of the major and notable socio-economic programs and policies contained within the bill.

Contents of the Relief Bill:
  • CalFresh Assistance: CalFresh is a food assistance program run by California through the Federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) program targeting low-income families and individuals ("CalFresh"). The stimulus bill provides funds to assist potentially-eligible students in the higher education system in applying for CalFresh, and additional funds to support county-level program administration of the program ("Governor Newsom"). 
  • Child Care Aid: Within the bill, $400 million was allocated to help essential workers in affording child care expenses for their children by providing stipends to state-sponsored child care and preschool institutions (Escalante). 
  • Community College Student Relief: Another portion of the relief bill will consist of aid to students attending any of the state's community colleges, which is intended to help them stay in school during the pandemic (Escalante). A chunk of that allocation will assist former community college students who dropped out to return to school ("Governor Newsom"). 
  • COVID Hotel Isolation for Food-Related Essential Workers: Funds will also be provided for the "Housing for the Harvest" program, which allows agricultural and food-related essential workers to isolate in hotels if they come down with COVID-19 and are unable to isolate anywhere else ("CA COVID"; Escalante). 
  • One-Time Stimulus Check: The most notable aspect of the "Golden State Stimulus" is a one-time $600 stimulus check targeting low-income Californians ("CA COVID"). A vast majority of those eligible will get the payment by claiming the California Earned Income Tax credit (Nuttle), while others who have tax IDs and (generally) make under $75,000 can also apply for the payment, including immigrants. Residents who do not fall into these two categories, but already take part in existing social assistance programs, including the elderly and disabled, also qualify for the check (Gould). In total, around 5.7 million people are estimated to be eligible for the one-time payment (Nuttle). 
  • Relief Grants: 
    • Small Businesses: One of the main criticisms over Governor Newsom's handling of the pandemic has been the state's rules relating to business activities, which has hit businesses hard. The relief bill would give out additional (in addition to those set aside last year) grants to businesses conditional on having a plan to reopen or are already open (Gould). Businesses owned by women or minority groups will receive preferential treatment in receiving the grants (Nuttle). In addition to direct monetary support, certain business fees will be waived to further assist small businesses (Gould). Despite these measures to help businesses, some state Republicans criticized these measures, arguing that such harm would have been avoided without Newsom's past actions towards California businesses (Gould). 
    • Cultural Institution and Non-Profit Relief: In addition to for-profit businesses, non-profit cultural institutions will be eligible for similar grants through the relief bill (Nuttle). Further grants will be given to support food and diaper banks within the state (Gould). 
  • Budget Cuts: Several California agencies and institutions will receive budget cuts as a result of the bill, including the state's higher education system, child support programs, and housing programs targeting medium-income citizens ("CA COVID"). I was not able to find specific details about these cuts before this post was published, and so these cuts are not reflected on the appropriations table below. 
Fiscal Appropriations: Table 1 below summarizes the appropriations for the programs listed above. Note that not all of the programs and policies contained within the bill were covered on this blog post, reflected by the combined values not equaling the total appropriations. All monetary values per line-item are estimated. 

Table 1: "Golden State Stimulus" Appropriations Table


December 13, 2020

Four Public Policy Implications from The Other Wes Moore and Hillbilly Elegy

Four Public Policy Implications from The Other Wes Moore and Hillbilly Elegy

Introduction: After several weeks of election-related coverage, I'm finally ready to go back to The Other Wes Moore and Hillbilly Elegy, two books I initially covered in October. That initial post synthesized several common policy themes between the two books, some of which will be reiterated in today's post. With those themes in mind, today's post will go over several significant policy implications I found when reading both books, especially relating to social and economic policy. 

Social Policy Implications:
  • Ensuring all teenagers can finish high school is just as important as emphasizing college enrollment: Between Hillbilly Elegy and The Other Wes Moore, while both respective authors ended up attending college and becoming successful, both note instances of classmates and subjects who didn't finish high school, or came close to not. In Hillbilly Elegy, the chaotic family situation facing J.D. Vance led his academic performance to suffer in his first two years of high school, which almost led him to drop out (Vance 127-130; 151; 155). At the end of Hillbilly Elegy, Vance talked with teachers from his hometown, who expressed concern over society's heavy focus on college, noting that many students come from backgrounds unable to complete college, and need critical interventions much earlier in life (Vance 244-245). Meanwhile, in The Other Wes Moore, the other Wes Moore and his brother Tony became school dropouts early, turning to a life on the streets of Baltimore (Moore 56-59). Even when he returned to school after an incident that got him locked up briefly, his stint at school was short, and he returned to the streets (Moore, 109-110). These experiences show, in connection with the third policy implication, that while college is increasingly important to achieve the American Dream, if a teenager cannot finish high school, then they cannot achieve a college degree, much less find a high-quality job. 
  • Social capital is critical to help teenagers and young adults in achieving success, especially those from working- or low-income backgrounds: This policy implication was already discussed in detail on the first post, so I won't go into it too much. Nonetheless, as both Moore and Vance note in their respective books, social capital they gained through external experiences (e.g. college, the military) helped them on their respective paths to success, which would have been more difficult without. 
  • What happens outside school can have significant consequences on youth development: This implication can also apply as a theme that I didn't cover last time, but is one I consider critical to understanding Vance's and both Moores' (both the author and the "other") backgrounds, and what factors influenced their personal development. In particular, while both authors extensively talk about their educational experiences while growing up, a similar amount of time is spent talking about their non-educational life, and how said experiences contributed to their development. When growing up in the Bronx, while Author Moore was enrolled in an elite private school, he spent a significant amount of non-school (and school) time on the street, which included involvement in criminal activity that led to an encounter with the police (Moore 48, 76-84). Meanwhile, the other Wes Moore infrequently attended school before dropping out, and even when he did attend school, his non-school life was chaotic, as his father was absent from his life, his mother was a busy working mom, and much of his time was spent on the street (Moore 17-19, 30, 56-59). At the end of his book, Vance explicitly states that society and public policy (especially education policy) needs to increasingly consider what goes on in the non-school life of youth from communities experiencing socio-economic decline (Vance, 244-245). 
  • Unintended pregnancy, especially among teenagers, has serious negative externalities: In both books, Moore and Vance discuss cases of teenage pregnancy in their communities and the effects that it has on the parents and their personal and professional development. Most notably, after becoming a high school dropout, the other Moore impregnated his two teenage girlfriends multiple times, which put significant strain on his personal decisions and outlook (Moore 99-101, 110, 137-138). Going further, author Moore speculated that having several children to support may have been the downfall of other Moore, causing him to return to a life of crime post-Job Corps (Moore 181-182). In Vance's family, his cousin Gail was on track to enter college right after high school when she got pregnant, which threw her life into chaos, which included a straining of relations with her family (Vance 240-241). Fortunately, her life bounced back after she got a job, returned to school, and remarried (Vance 241). As these cases show, unintended pregnancies can have significant negative impacts on families and individuals, including family members and acquittances. 
Works Cited:

Moore, Wes. The Other Wes Moore. Spiegel and Grau: New York, 2011.

Vance, J.D. Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis. HarperCollins: New York, 2016.

December 03, 2020

Four Significant Social Policy Issues Facing the Incoming Government

Four Significant Social Policy Issues Facing the Incoming Government

Introduction: This post is a follow-up and derivative to a post-election post highlighting budget and fiscal policy issues facing the new president and Congress (regardless of Georgia's Senate runoffs). This post will be another discussion of policy issues facing the new government, with a focus on social policy-related issues. In particular, social policies meant to help Americans weather the ongoing pandemic's health-related and economic impacts will be significant issues come January, especially those under the CARES Act. 

The Four Issues:
  • Expiration of CARES Act Unemployment Benefits: During the 2020 general election season, I twice covered the status of legislation negotiations on a potential second CARES Act (or "CARES Act II"). However, as of publication time (12/3/2020 at 8pm PST), a new CARES Act equivalent has not passed both houses of Congress ("Second Stimulus"). As the end of the year approaches, some of the social welfare benefits implemented by the CARES Act are expiring, most of which intertwine with the other policy issues covered below. Among the benefits ending this month include the halt on Federal student loan repayments (Stratford) (discussed further below), the eviction moratorium (discussed further below) and unemployment insurance covering freelancers and self-employed workers, which is the focus of this paragraph (Iacurci). With these deadlines in mind, Congressional negotiations have continued, with a bipartisan bill recently introduced that would extend the CARES Act's unemployment benefits for four more months, although Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) opposes this idea. Both him and Democratic Minority leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) have introduced their own proposals, with the former providing less assistance to unemployed workers, and the latter providing an extension of "enhanced unemployment" through next October. At the state-level, some states have extended their unemployment benefits to cover extra weeks of unemployment after the New Year begins (Dolcourt and Gonzalez). 
  • The Costs of Child Care: Since pandemic-related measures were implemented, increased discussion has focused on the effects of rising costs of child care on working and low-income parents, especially those unable to work remotely (Fields and Heggeness; Jessen-Howard and Workman). As detailed on the first CARES Act post, the CARES Act did not include direct support to help parents pay for child care, but did provide support for child care providers to remain open and afford critical supplies, and a block grant to allow working parents to afford child care (Campbell and Smith). As detailed in the my previous post comparing and contrasting the different proposals, both the HEROES (House Democratic) and HEALS (Senate Republican) acts provide different policy ideas to address this issue. However, as neither have passed as of publication time ("Second Stimulus"), the issue of child care will almost certainly continue, especially with renewed stay-at-home measures and economic closures in many parts of the country. 
  • Residential Evictions: While this specific issue was also discussed earlier because of CARES Act-related programs addressing it, the expiration of said benefits would create a significant policy issues for the new government. As a result of a massive in COVID-related unemployment, more Americans than ever are at risk of eviction due to lower incomes and the need to provide for other essentials. The CARES Act included a moratorium halting nonpayment-based evictions of residents in Federally-backed properties and programs. While some states and locales have passed similar measures going further than the Federal legislation, the CARES Act only covers about half of all renters, and only allows tenants to delay rent payments, resulting in increased debt owed by tenants to landowners (Acosta et al.). Eviction advocates have warned that when the CARES Act moratorium expires this month, 40 million tenants could be at risk of eviction is no further action is taken. While lawmakers in Washington have generally supported rental assistance, no action has been taken on the issue, either on its own or as part of a larger stimulus package (Demsas). If no Federal-level action is taken before the moratorium expires, the new government in January will face this critical issue and the effects it could have on working-class Americans.  
  • Student Debt (Growth and Forgiveness Proposals): Aside from the expiration of student debt policies from the CARES Act, the state of aggregate and individual-level student debt in the U.S. remains a significant problem. Right now, it is estimated that almost $1.7 trillion of student debt exists within the United States, while individual borrowers owe an average of $36,000 (Rindlisbacher). During his general election campaign, Biden's student debt proposal focused on eliminating $10,000 of student debt per borrower (Murakami). After Biden's projected win as President-Elect, prominent Democrats began to suggest for him to go further than his campaign ideas, arguing that Biden could eliminate up to $50,000 of individual student debt with an Executive Order once in the White House (Berger). Furthermore, progressives have continued to discuss broader student loan forgiveness ideas, including wiping away all student debt, and making higher education free in the future (Fearnow). These ideas have been opposed by Republicans and some Democrats, who argue that such measures are unfair to those who have not attended college (Fearnow; Vesoulis) or went to college without taking on much or any debt (Fearnow; Vesoulis). The Trump administration's current student loan policy emphasizes initiating income-based repayment plans, temporarily suspending loan payments during the pandemic, and stopping collections of loans in default (Fearnow). Regardless, the constantly-increasing bubble of American higher education debt is a significant ongoing issue going into the new Congress, especially if no alternative or extension is implemented to offset the expiring CARES Act student loan policies.
Works Cited:

Acosta, Sonya, Anna Bailey, and Peggy Bailey. "Extend CARES Act Eviction Moratorium, Combine With Rental Assistance to Promote Housing Stability." Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 27 Jul. 2020, www.cbpp.org/research/housing/extend-cares-act-eviction-moratorium-combine-with-rental-assistance-to-promote. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Berger, Rob. "Will Biden Cancel Your Student Loans In January?." Forbes, 30 Nov. 2020, www.forbes.com/sites/robertberger/2020/11/30/will-biden-cancel-your-student-loans-in-january/?sh=1b1473fac7b1. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Campbell, Megan, and Linda Smith. "CCDBG Funds in the CARES Act." Bipartisan Policy Center, 2 Apr. 2020, bipartisanpolicy.org/explainer/ccdbg-funds-in-the-cares-act/. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Demsas, Jerusalem. "We know how to prevent up to 40 million people from being evicted. It’s up to Congress to do it.." Vox, 27 Nov. 2020, www.vox.com/21569601/eviction-moratorium-cdc-covid-19-congress-rental-assistance-rent-crisis. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Dolcourt, Jessica, and Oscar Gonzalez. "Stimulus deal: Time is running out on these 5 benefits." CNET, 2 Dec. 2020, www.cnet.com/personal-finance/stimulus-deal-time-is-running-out-on-these-5-benefits/. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Fearnow, Benjamin. "Student Loan Debt 'Your Own Fault': Conservatives Blast Biden Forgiveness Proposals." Newsweek, 21 Nov. 2020, www.newsweek.com/student-loan-debt-your-own-fault-conservatives-blast-biden-forgiveness-proposals-1549279. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Fields, Jason, and Misty Heggeness. "Working Moms Bear Brunt of Home Schooling While Working During COVID-19." United States Census Bureau, 18 Aug. 2020, www.census.gov/library/stories/2020/08/parents-juggle-work-and-child-care-during-pandemic.html. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Jessen-Howard, Steven, and Simon Workman. "The True Cost of Providing Safe Child Care During the Coronavirus Pandemic." Center for American Progress, 3 Sept. 2020, www.americanprogress.org/issues/early-childhood/reports/2020/09/03/489900/true-cost-providing-safe-child-care-coronavirus-pandemic/. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Johnson, Marty. "Inequality of student loan debt underscores possible Biden policy shift." The Hill, 28 Nov. 2020, thehill.com/policy/finance/527646-inequality-of-student-loan-debt-underscores-possible-biden-policy-shift. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Iacurci, Greg. "14 million workers face losing unemployment benefits at the end of December." CNBC, 25 Nov. 2020, www.cnbc.com/2020/11/25/14-million-workers-face-losing-unemployment-benefits-at-the-end-december.html. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Keith, Katie. "Supreme Court Arguments: Even If Mandate Falls, Rest Of Affordable Care Act Looks Likely To Be Upheld." HealthAffairs, 11 Nov. 2020, www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20201111.916623/full/. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Murakami, Kery. "Groups Call on Biden to Cancel Student Debt." InsideHigherEd, 19 Nov. 2020, www.insidehighered.com/news/2020/11/19/biden-urged-cancel-student-debt. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Rindlisbacher, Christof. "Joe Biden Should Absolutely Erase Student Debt via Executive Order." Jacobin Magazine, 17 Nov. 2020, www.jacobinmag.com/2020/11/joe-biden-student-debt-forgiveness-executive-order. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

"Second stimulus check: latest on US coronavirus relief bill." Diario AS US, 29 Nov. 2020, en.as.com/en/2020/11/29/latest_news/1606650512_181016.html. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Stratford, Michael. "Education Department pauses student loan bills, awaiting Congress or Trump to act." Politico, 1 Dec. 2020, www.politico.com/news/2020/12/01/education-department-student-loans-442053. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

Vesoulis, Abby. "'This Feels Like the Closest We’ve Ever Been.' Why Growing Demands for Student Debt Forgiveness Could Be Joe Biden's First Presidential Test." Time, 1 Dec. 2020, time.com/5915441/biden-student-debt-relief/. Accessed 3 Dec. 2020. 

October 15, 2020

The Role of Social Capital in Elite Private Education: A Personal Connection

The Role of Social Capital in Elite Private Education: A Personal Connection

Introduction:
After the unveiling of the higher education admissions scandal last year, discussion began about why anyone would want to cheat their way (or their childrens') into elite private (and public) schools, especially Ivy Leagues and similar public universities. Much of the discussion focused on the social capital gained from attending highly-ranked universities, especially for those aspiring to enter high-level, high-paying job fields immediately after college (Goodkind; Kingkade). For those are accepted at said universities, simply being able to go there allows students to gain access to immense social capital to assist with achieving high-level jobs (Kingkade). Even for those not directly interested in going into very high-level job fields, simply going to a high-level school grants a significantly-high social status and associated privileges (Goodkind). This concept links back to what I discussed in my literature review of Hillbilly Elegy and The Other Wes Moore about the role of social capital in moving up the socio-economic ladder. "It's not what you know, but who" is a phrase I have heard frequently since entering undergraduate, although I probably heard it before that, and is one that encapsulates the allure of elite private (and public) universities for aspiring students and their parents.  

J.D. Vance's Experience: In the second half of his autobiography Hillbilly Elegy, author J.D. Vance detailed his experience attaining his law degree from Yale after completing his undergraduate studies from a state school (Ohio State), and coming from a Rust Belt middle-class background before that (Vance, 216). Among other aspects of his law school experience, Vance extensively discusses that like himself, many of his peers who attended Yale Law School took advantage of the school's resources and social capital, such as prominent lawyers, public officials, and writers working there, as a means to further their professional goals (Vance, 215-221). In particular, instructor Amy Choa (another famous author) assisted Vance with applying to become a court clerk, which he eventually achieved. However, he did not take the position after learning from another instructor about the realties of court clerkships (Vance, 217-219). In addition, through his Yale Law School experience, Vance also gained access to other connections and mentors, notably ex-Indiana Governor Mitch Daniels (R) (Vance, 220-221). All combined, these experiences that Vance went through on his journey through law school demonstrate the extensive social capital that elite institutions such as Yale offer, which in turn allows students to come out prepared (or already securing one) to take on high-level job positions. 

My Personal Anecdote: In Fall 2017, when considering Master of Public Policy (M.P.P.) programs to apply for, I decided to not only apply for several high-level public schools, but also try my hand with at least one private school with a good M.P.P. track. Since I had only applied to public schools for undergraduate, and considering how much I had advanced academically and skill-wise, I wanted to challenge myself and see if I could successfully assert myself for a high-level private school program. In the end, I chose to try for Georgetown University's M.P.P. program as the private school, along with several public schools. When the university decisions came the following March, I was shocked to find out that I had gotten into Georgetown. In the end, for personal reasons, I chose to attend the nearby University of Maryland in College Park. This is a decision I do not regret, as I gained a significant amount of knowledge, social capital, and further passion for what I like to do (that is, talking about, writing about, and analyzing topics related to public policy, current events, and public affairs). Even still, being accepted at Georgetown, a high-level private institution with a top-quality reputation, is something I am still proud about, even though I did not take the offer. 

In addition to wanting to try for a private school "just because," there is another significant reason why I was potentially interested in doing my graduate degree at an elite private school. Like J.D. Vance, this reason was to take advantage of the social capital provided by schools such as Georgetown, which I knew would greatly assist my policy aspirations. In particular, I knew that simply completing my degree and being able to say that I got it from "Georgetown" would have provided a significant boost to my professional aspirations due to the to the school's name being associated with having a high-quality education. As stated earlier I do not regret choosing UMD to get my graduate studies from, despite knowing the prestige Georgetown would bring on me. 

When the college admissions scandal was unveiled last year, it made me think about why I wanted to attend Georgetown's Public Policy school, and I realized it was for the same reasons that the parents implicated in the scandal wanted their kids to get into high-level public and private schools. Like them, it was to legitimize my social position and gain exclusive access to human and social capital I perceived was better at a private institution such as Georgetown. Yet, I feel that the education I still received at UMD and related external experiences was just as sufficient. 

Works Cited:

Goodkind, Nicole. "An End to Affirmative Action? Why the College Admissions Scandal Could Fulfill Critics' Wish to Scrap Race-Based Program." Newsweek, 22 Mar. 2019, www.newsweek.com/2019/04/12/affirmative-action-college-admissions-statistics-scandal-1372652.html. Accessed 15 Oct. 2020. 

Kingkade, Tyler. "This Is Why Canadian Universities Don’t Have College Admissions Scandals." The Huffington Post, 26 Apr. 2019, www.huffpost.com/entry/college-admissions-scam-inequality-university-canada_n_5cc16918e4b0ad77ff7fd4e8. Accessed 15 Oct. 2020. 

Vance, J.D. Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis. HarperCollins: New York, 2016. 

October 11, 2020

Common Policy-Related Themes between The Other Wes Moore and Hillbilly Elegy

Author's Notes: Today's post will not be a promotion of either book discussed below, but will provide a discussion of important themes shared between the two desperate autobiographies by two authors who never interacted with each other, but faced similar situations.

September 13, 2020

An Update on CARES Act II Negotiations

An Update on CARES Act II Negotiations

Introduction: About a month ago, I explored the CARES Act's original programs and policies, and compared it with the proposed HEROES (Democratic House proposal) and HEALS (Republican Senate proposal) Acts. Since that point, negotiations over which proposal will become an extension of the CARES Act (which I refer to as "CARES Act II") are still ongoing, with several significant disagreements between the two parties in the way. Today's post will provide a more detailed summary of the negotiation status and what some of the major disputes are between the parties over what the final bill should contain. Note that the information presented below is accurate at the time of this article's publication (9/13/2020 at 8pm PST). This will also be one of the few posts I make that pertains too American Politics and public policy, as the policy proposal(s) in question is (are) still being debated and negotiated over, with neither having been passed in both Congressional Houses. 

Current Status: Since the original CARES Act post came out in early August, no CARES Act extension has passed both Houses of Congress as of the publication of this post (Rogers). Last week, a modified version ("Skinny Bill") of the Republican Senate proposal (The "HEALS Act") failed to pass the Senate's 60-vote threshold to overcome the Democratic filibuster (Raju; Rogers). Every Senate Democrat, along with Kentucky Republican Rand Paul (R), voted against the proposal (Rogers). 

Meanwhile, as of now, the Democratic House proposal, the status of the "HEROES Act," has not changed since passing the House in May. Prior to the "Skinny Bill" Senate vote last week, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D, CA-9) urged the Senate to consider and pass it (Schonter). 

Main Areas of Disagreement:
  • Second Stimulus Check: One of the top disagreements between Congressional Democrats and Republicans is whether CARES Act II will contain a second round of stimulus checks. The "Skinny Bill" does not enact a new stimulus check (Long). Note that the original HEALS Act contained provisions for an additional stimulus check if passed (Adamczyk). As noted on the earlier blog post, the HEROES Act would include another round of stimulus checks (Long). Despite this conflict, President Trump has continued to support the inclusion of a second stimulus check (Fink, "Trump Wants"). Recent polling showed that 70% of Americans, including over 60% of Republicans and Independent voters, support a second stimulus check (Bieber). 
  • Second Stimulus Check Eligibility: Going beyond whether there should even be a second stimulus check, debate continues over whether eligibility should be expanded from the CARES Act. In one area of agreement, both the HEROES and HEALS Acts would expand coverage to include adult dependents, especially college students and elderly Americans (Raymone). Additional contention continues over whether immigrants (including undocumented) should qualify for the stimulus checks, with Republicans arguing that undocumented non-citizens specifically should not be receiving benefits because of their status (Fink, "Should Undocumented"). Meanwhile, supporters of allowing immigrants to receive benefits argue that because most immigrants pay taxes and contribute to their communities, they should be eligible for such benefits (Garcia). The HEROES Act specifically would allow immigrants with IRS tax IDs (i.e. those who have paid income taxes) to qualify for the checks (Nerea). 
  • Unemployment Assistance Extension: As detailed on the previous post, whether to extend the $600/week unemployment insurance further is among the most contentious policies in the current debate. Like stimulus checks, no agreement has come regarding whether the CARES Act level of unemployment insurance should be continued further (Colby and Dolcourt). Like before, the HEROES Act would extend the $600/week unemployment insurance through next January, whle the "Skinny Bill" would provide $300/week through December. By comparison, the original HEALS Act would have provided unemployment benefits as a proportion of workers' pre-COVID income, and would supplement President Trump's recent program (see below) (Lobosco et al.). 
    • Last month, the Trump administration started the Lost Wages Assistance Program, which would provide a $300/week Federal subsidy to unemployed workers through the states. Qualifying workers would have to prove that their unemployment is due to COVID-19, and would already have to be receiving benefits. With no agreed-on proposal in Congress, most states have signed onto the program and begun to pay out. This program will only last 6 weeks from inception due to limited funding (Iacurci). In addition, existing CARES Act unemployment insurance funding to states lasts until November (Holzhauer). 
  • Education Funding: One of the most notable aspects of the HEALS Act that Republicans have touted in recent weeks is whether Coronavirus aid should be given to private schools and families of students attending such schools. The HEALS Act included funding for private schools, something Democrats and other public school supporters have opposed (Winter). Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) recently pitched a proposal for tax cuts aimed at private schools to make them more affordable for families and provide more options. Likewise, advocates of public schools have opposed this measure, although Senator McConnell raised concerns that this proposal may not be accepted by the whole Senate Republican caucus ("Cruz's Demand"). Furthermore, both the HEALS Act and the "Skinny Bill" would tie education funding to schools re-opening for in-person instruction, something the HEROES Act would not (Lobosco et al.). 
  • Institutional Liability Protection: In addition to direct fiscal assistance for individuals, families, and businesses, the HEALS Act (and the "Skinny Bill" derivative) contains a liability protection clause protecting employers from COVID-related lawsuits. Specifically, it would protect from lawsuits alleging that said institution did not take appropriate steps to prevent the transmission of COVID-19 to workers. Lack of such actions would have to constitute "gross negligence" and would have to be proven to be a direct cause of a worker contracting the virus. Current Democrat proposals would not include a lawsuit liability provision, instead providing more assistance to helping employers protect workers (Lobosco et al.). 
  • Assistance for Local and State Governments: The original CARES Act provided significant financial assistance to state, local, and tribal governments, which bear a significant fiscal and financial burden from the virus's economic effects (Sanchez). The recent "Skinny Bill" would not have included state and local assistance, although the HEALS Act would provide more time for states to utilize existing funding. Meanwhile, the HEROES Act would provide another package of fiscal aid to state and local governments to help cover fiscal shortfalls and pay expenses (Lobosco et al.).
  • Total Appropriation: In addition to specific programs and policies between the different proposals, the overall amount appropriated for both bills is a minor flash-point in current negotiations. Generally, Republican proposals have aimed to reduce the overall fiscal cost to the Federal government, with the "skinny bill" topping at $1 trillion. Meanwhile, the HEROES Act's current cost is estimated to be $2.2 trillion, less than the original estimate of $3.2 trillion (Godbout). 
Works Cited:

Adamczyk, Adam. "The GOP’s ‘skinny’ coronavirus relief bill doesn’t include a second round of stimulus checks." CNBC, 9 Sept. 2020, www.cnbc.com/2020/09/09/gops-skinny-coronavirus-relief-bill-doesnt-include-stimulus-checks.html. Accessed 12 Sept. 2020.

Bieber, Christy. "70% of Americans Want a Second Stimulus Check. What's the Holdup?" The Motley Fool, 12 Sept. 2020, www.fool.com/investing/2020/09/12/70-of-americans-want-a-second-stimulus-check-whats/. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Colby, Clifford, and Jessica Dolcourt. "If a stimulus bill passes, these are the benefits Americans could get." CNET, last modified 11 Sept. 2020, www.cnet.com/personal-finance/if-a-stimulus-bill-passes-these-are-the-benefits-americans-could-get/. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

"Cruz's Demand for 'School Choice' May Derail Coronavirus Stimulus Checks." ValueWalk, 7 Sept. 2020, www.valuewalk.com/2020/09/coronavirus-stimulus-checks-cruz/. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Fink, Jenny. "Should Undocumented Immigrants Receive Stimulus Checks? Trump Says No, Vermont Says Yes." Newsweek, 10 Sept. 2020, www.newsweek.com/should-undocumented-immigrants-receive-stimulus-checks-trump-says-no-vermont-says-yes-1530979. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020.

---. "Trump Wants to Use $300 Billion for Stimulus Checks, Here's Who Wouldn't Qualify." Newsweek, 7 Sept. 2020, www.newsweek.com/trump-wants-use-300-billion-stimulus-checks-heres-who-wouldnt-qualify-1530135. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Garcia, Jacqueline. "Undocumented immigrants could qualify for $600 if Newsom signs pandemic assistance bill." CAMatters, 5 Sept. 2020, calmatters.org/california-divide/2020/09/undocumented-immigrants-pandemic-relief-bill/. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Godbout, Ted. "Senate Fails to Advance Scaled-back COVID-19 Stimulus Bill." National Association of Plan Advisors, 12 Sept. 2020, www.napa-net.org/news-info/daily-news/senate-fails-advance-scaled-back-covid-19-stimulus-bill. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Holzhauer, Brett. "What Could Happen Now That The Skinny Stimulus Bill Failed." Forbes, 11 Sept. 2020, www.forbes.com/advisor/personal-finance/what-could-happen-now-that-the-skinny-stimulus-bill-failed/. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Iacurci, Greg. "Trump’s unemployment program pays up to $1,800 in extra benefits to workers who qualify." CNBC, 11 Sept. 2020, www.cnbc.com/2020/09/11/lost-wages-assistance-pays-up-to-1800-in-extra-unemployment-benefits.html. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Lobosco, Katie, Tami Luhby, and Jeanne Sahadi. "Here's what's in the GOP's 'skinny' stimulus bill -- and what's missing." WENY, 8 Sept. 2020, www.weny.com/story/42604587/heres-whats-in-the-gops-skinny-stimulus-bill-and-whats-missing. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Long, Emily. "Second stimulus check for $1,200 isn't off the table yet — here's where talks stand." Tom's Guide, 10 Sept. 2020, www.tomsguide.com/news/stimulus-check-2-skinny-status. Accessed 12 Sept. 2020. 

Menton, Jessica. "'We shouldn’t have to beg': Americans struggle without unemployment aid as Congress stalls on extending benefits." USA Today, 25 Aug. 2020, www.usatoday.com/story/money/2020/08/25/unemployment-benefits-americans-struggle-with-delayed-300-unemployment-coronavirus-stimulus/3411294001/. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Narea, Nicole. "Immigrants were largely overlooked in the US’s coronavirus response. The latest relief bill aims to fix that." Vox, 15 May 2020, www.vox.com/2020/5/15/21257361/heroes-act-coronavirus-bill-immigrants. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Raju, Manu. "Amid GOP divisions, McConnell sets stage for showdown stimulus vote with Democrats." CNN, 8 Sept. 2020, www.cnn.com/2020/09/08/politics/mitch-mcconnell-gop-skinny-plan/index.html. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Raymone, Allison DeNisco. "Under 25? Here's how you might get your own stimulus check money." CNET, 13 Sept. 2020, www.cnet.com/personal-finance/under-25-heres-how-you-might-get-your-own-stimulus-check-money/. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Rogers, Alex. "After negotiations falter, Senate fails to advance Republican bill addressing coronavirus pandemic." CNN, 10 Sept. 2020, www.cnn.com/2020/09/10/politics/stimulus-package-vote-republican-senators/index.html. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Sanchez, Humberto. "Indy DC Download: Senate Democrats Block GOP's Skinny pandemic bill as standoff on aid continues." The Nevada Independent, 13 Sept. 2020, thenevadaindependent.com/article/indy-dc-download-senate-democrats-block-gops-skinny-pandemic-bill-as-standoff-on-aid-continues. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

Schonter, Allison. "Second Stimulus Check: Nancy Pelosi Continues Pushing for HEROES Act to Be Passed Ahead of GOP Vote." Pop Culture, 9 Sept. 2020, popculture.com/trending/news/second-stimulus-check-nancy-pelosi-continues-pushing-heroes-act-passed-ahead-gop-vote/. Accessed 12 Sept. 2020. 

"Stimulus Deal Unlikely Until After the Election." WKTV, 10 Sept. 2020, www.wktv.com/content/news/572374512.html. Accessed 12 Sept. 2020. 

Winter, Allison. "U.S. Senate Republicans Trying To Insert Private School Tuition Into The Next COVID-19 Aid Package." Patch Across Florida, 4 Sept. 2020, patch.com/florida/across-fl/u-s-senate-republicans-trying-insert-private-school-tuition-next-covid-19-aid. Accessed 13 Sept. 2020. 

August 23, 2020

A Comparison of State-Level Differences in Asian-American Poverty

Author's Notes: You all might notice a major change to the content of this blog, that being the variety and sophistication of data visualizations representing raw data. After initially learning and using Tableau for my graduate capstone project in the Spring, I have been practicing data visualization creation offline. Now, I am please to announce that I will start creating and using Tableau-created visualizations to supplement qualitative information presented on this blog, and may still use Excel-created visualizations in some situations. For today, I will post just the static (non-interactive) versions, and will update this page with the interactive online versions once I make my Tableau public account and publish my visualizations (past and future) there. 

August 16, 2020

Explaining Global Child Mortality through Econometrics

Author's Notes: Tonight's edition of The Parmeter Politics and Policy Record is a special two-part edition; the first part, examining Florida's House primaries occurring this coming Tuesday, can be found here. I was originally going to publish both articles at the normal hour (8pm Pacific Time), but because of the possibility of rolling blackouts hitting Fresno due to the ongoing heat wave, I published both earlier, at 5:30pm. Note that this publication time change will be temporary. 

While my interests in politics and public policy are mostly domestic (i.e. within the US), I also have a secondary interest in international politics and economics, something I previously had an increased interest in prior to the 2016 (United States) Presidential Election. The following post was an assignment in the same course where I also completed the two domestic consumption regression model posts. In this post, I create econometric models to predict and explain child mortality in the developing and emerging world, including inserting fixed and random effects to control for country-specific results. 

August 05, 2020

Comparing the CARES Act with the HEROES and HEALS Acts

Author's Notes: The information presented below regarding the HEALS and HEROES Acts are accurate as of publication time (8pm PST on 8/5/2020). I do not plan to update this post once the House and Senate agree on and pass a compromise bill, but might discuss in-depth whichever final bill becomes law. 

     8/9/2020 UPDATE: Per a significant announcement presented today, I corrected a significant mistake with the information originally presented below. On the original version, I stated that the Economic Impact Payments (or "stimulus checks") were monthly payments, whereas in reality, they are one-time payments. If you are reading this, the information presented below is corrected from the original version. As stated on the linked announcement, I take full responsibility for, and apologize for the mistake I made here. 

July 19, 2020

Examining the State-Level Minimum Wage-Income Inequality Relationship

Examining the State-Level Minimum Wages-Income Inequality Relationship

Introduction: Throughout the social and economic policy analysis community, the effects of the minimum wage on various socio-economic indicators are extensively studied and debated. One of these significant socio-economic indicators is income inequality. One argument suggests that income inequality is reduced by increasing the minimum wage, as doing so raises the income of low-income workers, thus reducing inequality with those whose incomes fall above the income line (Thompson). On the other hand, a 2014 Congressional Budget Report suggested that the positive effects of a higher minimum wage on income inequality is balanced by higher unemployment for some low-income workers as a result of losing jobs to the higher minimum wage (i.e. higher cost to retain) (Alsalam et al., 1). This in turn could lead to an increase in inequality through the decline of former workers' wages, thus balancing out against the rise in wages of still-employed workers. Based on this debate, today's will take a close look at state-level minimum wages and evaluate whether higher minimum wages are associated with a significant change in income inequality at the state level. 

Methodology: State-level minimum wage data from 2018 (to match up with the most recent Gini coefficient data, below) was extracted from the Department of Labor's website. Any states that did not have a state-level minimum wage were given the Federal minimum wage. Minnesota, Nevada and Oklahoma were excluded because their state-level minimum wages are applied differently to firms depending on firm size ("Changes to"). 

The explanatory variable (income inequality) will be operationalized using the Gini coefficient, which ranges from 0 to 1 and measures the distribution of income by percentiles within a jurisdiction (Duffin). In other words, in an ideal world, if the bottom 20% of a population received 20% of the jurisdiction's income, the next 20% received 20%, and so on, the Gini coefficient would be 0, representing a perfect distribution. On the other hand, if one person held all of the jurisdiction's income and everybody else made no income, then the Gini coefficient would be 1, representing perfect inequality. State-level Gini coefficient data came from Statista, and was most recently available from 2018 (Duffin). 

Aside from the independent and explanatory variables, I will also look at whether additional third variables are associated with income inequality. Variables that are related to state-level legislation and their sources are listed below:
  • Right-to-Work Legislation: "Right to work" laws prohibit unions from charging non-unionized employees dues that fund union initiatives, or to even force employees to join a union ("Right to work frequently"). The 2010s witnessed a major surge of right-to-work laws being passed in many states, and even nationally, which President Trump proposed in 2017 (Bruno and Manzo IV, 1). In addition to contributing to a decline in union membership among workers (explored more in another variable, below), such laws have been argued to be (indirectly, and somewhat directly) responsible for the increase in income inequality through decreasing unionization, which leads to lower wages among workers ("The Impact"). This connection is due to the fact that when unions are stronger and have more bargaining power, they are able to be more assertive on employers to pay higher wages, thus reducing inequality (Hiltzik). Right-to-work laws are argued to increase income inequality through weakening unions as a result of reduced union membership, thus giving unions less bargaining power (Hiltzik). Data on right-to-work legislation status by state (as of 2018) was taken from the National Right to Work Committee's website, and each state was coded "1" if they had right-to-work legislation in force, and "0" if not. 
  • Highest Income Bracket Tax Rates: One of the most basic socio-economic rationales of the income tax is that it redistributes wealth from higher-income individuals to lower-income individuals, thus helping improve the lives of those with little income (McLure). In the United States, individuals are levied the income tax that varies on what income bracket they fall into, with the highest bracket receiving the highest tax rate (Scarboro). Data on state-level income tax bracket rates in 2018 came from The Tax Foundation (Scarboro). Note that in 2018, 7 states did not have an income tax (Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming) (Scarboro), and were coded as "0.0%" for that variable.
In addition, the following socio-demographic and -economic variables that are independent of state-level legislation will be studied to understand similar effects:
  • Post-Secondary Degree Attainment: In the discussion of American poverty and income inequality, a topic that has been extensively discussed is the "college premium," in which college-educated individuals have seen significant increases in income and employment opportunities in recent years than non-college educated individuals (Barscher et al., 21). This variable will be operationalized using the college degree attainment rate by state in 2018, whose data I retrieved from The Chronicle of Higher Education. The data was broken down by attainment levels; I manually calculated the percent of each state's population by combining bachelor's, professional, and doctorate degree attainment together ("Compare the States"). 
  • Unionization Rate: In connection with right-to-work laws noted above, declining (private sector) unionization and union membership regardless of "right-to-work" laws has been argued to be a significant cause behind recent increases in income inequality (Hiltzik). Data on each state's union membership rate out of the total labor force came from the Bureau of Labor Statistics ("Hawaii and New York"). 
Statistical analysis will consist of summary statistics and correlation While doing multi-OLS regression would likely reveal some critical relationships between the variables being studied, I currently don't have the means to conduct such analysis at the moment, but if I do get access, I will follow-up on this post and conduct further analysis. 

Results:
Table 1: Summary Statistics
Notes: There are 48 total observations. All standard deviations were found using the Excel function "STDEV.P". Values in red under the "quartiles" column indicate values within the middle 50% of each variable's distribution.

Table 2: Correlation Matrix:

Summary statistics for each variable is included in Table 1. Per the correlational results in Table 2, neither the independent or the control variables have a strong correlation (either direction) with the explanatory, although some of the correlational directions seem interesting based on research presented above. Particularly, the main IV-DV relationship is positively-correlated, meaning that an increase in state-level minimum wages is associated with an increase in the gini coefficient (representing income inequality). Even more surprising is that states with higher top marginal tax rates have an even stronger positive relationship with their respective Gini coefficients. In addition, the relationship between each state's right-to-work laws and unionization %, with respective Gini coefficients is unusual as the former is negatively associated with the Gini coefficient while the latter is positively associated. This indicates that at the macro-level, higher unionization is associated with higher Gini coefficient values, and that "right-to-work" laws are associated with lower Gini coefficients. Finally, higher levels of post-secondary educational attainment ("PSAttain") is positively correlated with higher Gini coefficient values. 

Conclusion and Implications: While the results of this study seem to show significant results, there are several important limitations to keep in mind. First, this study is a macro-level data survey, and does not take into account a variety of micro-level factors that could influence income inequality, as well as income inequality within states. Second, I was unable to study several critical factors that have been widely-cited as contributing to recent increases in income inequality, particularly globalization, automation, political factors, and Federal-level policies (such as the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act). Finally, when talking about income inequality in this context, I only looked at the absolute level and extent of income inequality, and not the actual relative situation at a macro- or micro-level. In other words, a jurisdiction could have high income inequality per se, but where even low-income residents have a reasonable standard of living and sufficient opportunities to improve their socio-economic status above a level that is considered "reasonable." 

Despite these factors, there are two critical implications of this study's results. The first is that conducting an econometric analysis is critical to further understanding the interaction between the variables used in this study. Second, the results of this study also show that in connection to what was said above, more than just state-level policies likely have an impact on income inequality, something that I did not study for this post. Regardless, the results of this study contribute to the ever-growing body of discussion and research about income inequality, one of the most pressing policy issues of the 21st century. 

Works Cited: 

Alsama, Nabeel, William Carrington, Molly Dahl, and Justin Falk. "The Effects of a Minimum Wage Increase on Employment and Family Income." Congressional Budget Office, Feb. 2014, www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/113th-congress-2013-2014/reports/44995-MinimumWage.pdf. 

Bartscher, Alina, Moritz Kuhn, and Moritz Schularick. "The College Wealth Divide:
Education and Inequality in America, 1956-2016." St. Louis Federal Reserve Bank, 13 Dec. 2018, www.stlouisfed.org/~/media/files/pdfs/hfs/is-college-worth it/bartscher_kuhn_schularick_college_wealth_divide.pdf?la=en. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

Bruno, Robert, and Frank Manzo IV. "The Impact of “Right-to-Work” Laws on Labor Market Outcomes in Three Midwest States: Evidence from Indiana, Michigan, and Wisconsin (2010–2016)." Project for Middle Class Renewal, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 3 Apr. 2017, ler.illinois.edu/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/RTW-in-the-Midwest-2010-2016.pdf. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

Hiltzik, Michael. "IMF agrees: Decline of union power has increased income inequality." Los Angeles Times, 25 Mar. 2015, www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-mh-imf-agrees-loss-of-union-power-20150325-column.html. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

Jordan, Jeffrey, Aparna Mathur,Abdul Munasib, and Devesh Roy. "Did right-to-work laws impactincomeinequality?Evidence from U.S. states using the Synthetic Control Method." American Enterprise Institute, Mar. 2016, www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/rtw-laws-inequality.pdf." Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

McLure, Charles. "Income tax." Brittanica, last revised 20 Sept. 2017, www.britannica.com/topic/income-tax/Family-factors-and-personal-deductions. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

"Right to work frequently asked questions." National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation, www.nrtw.org/right-to-work-frequently-asked-questions/. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

"The Impact of Right-to-Work laws and declining unionization on the economy." Service Employees International Union 49, 14 Nov. 2017, www.seiu49.org/wp-content/blogs.dir/60/files/2018/04/TWR_RTW-FactsSheet.pdf. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

Thompson, Derek. "The Labor Department's New Report isn't So Gloomy." The Atlantic, 5 Oct. 2019, www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/10/labor-departments-new-report-isnt-so-gloomy/599491/. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

Data Sources:

“Changes in Basic Minimum Wages in non-farm employment under state law: Selected Years 
1968 to 2018.” United States Department of Labor, last revised Jan. 2020, www.dol.gov/whd/state/stateMinWageHis.htm. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

"Compare the States Almanac 2018-Demographics." The Chronicle of Higher Education, 19 Aug. 2018, www.chronicle.com/interactives/almanac-2018. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

Duffin, Erin. "Gini coefficient as a measure for household income distribution inequality for U.S. states in 2018." Statista, 11 Oct. 2019, www.statista.com/statistics/227249/greatest-gap-between-rich-and-poor-by-us-state/. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

"Hawaii and New York had highest union membership rates, the Carolinas the lowest, in 2018." Bureau of Labor Statistics, United States Department of Labor, 22 Feb. 2019, www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2019/hawaii-and-new-york-had-highest-union-membership-rates-the-carolinas-the-lowest-in-2018.htm." Accessed 19 Jul. 2020.

"Right to work states timeline." National Right to Work Committee, nrtwc.org/facts/state-right-to-work-timeline-2016/. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020. 

Scarboro, Morgan. "State Individual Income Tax Rates and Brackets for 2018." The Tax Foundation, 5 Mar. 2018, taxfoundation.org/state-individual-income-tax-rates-brackets-2018/. Accessed 19 Jul. 2020.